Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   How Unethical Do You Think Cloning of a Dead Dog Is? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=19766)

EyeballGrowth 02.17.2008 11:40 PM

The only people who are against cloning are religious. They are against it because they don't want proof that humans can create other humans. Only God can do that.

There is nothing wrong with cloning. It can have lifesaving benefits. Read about it sometime

Dead-Air 02.18.2008 01:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EyeballGrowth
The only people who are against cloning are religious. They are against it because they don't want proof that humans can create other humans. Only God can do that.

There is nothing wrong with cloning. It can have lifesaving benefits. Read about it sometime


A whole lot of oversimplifications there. You'll find plenty of people who are against cloning for reasons other than religion, though I'd agree they often are ruled by dogmatism. There are just as many lefties against cloning as religious conservatives. Their argument is of course similar - that we shouldn't be messing with nature because nature knows best (and indeed, some, though not all of them would capitalized Nature as a diety).

Your other oversimplification is to say "there is nothing wrong with cloning". While I'm completely in favor of pursuing this biotechnology, that would be with the caveat that it be done very cautiously. Yes it can save lives, it can also open the door to mutated cells finding their way into our food supply, our medical treatments, and ultimately our gene pool. These are real, very serious, concerns that most scientists carefully work under. It is perfectly reasonable to have some non-extremist trepidation about the inevitable rogues who may not.

█████████ 02.18.2008 11:45 AM

this is rather stupid than unethical or disturbing.

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 11:52 AM

i'd clone my cat if it was cheap. he's got an awesome personality, which we know it's over 90% genetic. best cat EVER. unfortunately i adopted him de-nutted, which means he can't propagate his excellent genes. and he's not going to live forever, BUT I AM. so-- it makes perfect sense.

█████████ 02.18.2008 11:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
i'd clone my cat if it was cheap. he's got an awesome personality, which we know it's over 90% genetic. best cat EVER. unfortunately i adopted him de-nutted, which means he can't propagate his excellent genes. and he's not going to live forever, BUT I AM. so-- it makes perfect sense.

clones are genetically identical but have different personalities.

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 12:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by █████████
clones are genetically identical but have different personalities.


well i've known enought twins to know---yes i don't expect identical personalities (obviousy) but close enough. i'd clone the little bastard-- end of story. you can't stop me.

█████████ 02.18.2008 12:15 PM

how selfish of you.

but hey, i'm not trying to stop anything.

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by █████████
how selfish of you.


selfishness is natural and healthy. i don't see you in line to be crucified.

✌➬ 02.18.2008 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
selfishness is natural and healthy. i don't see you in line to be crucified.


Yes it is healthy be selfish. Repeat, "It is only me, there is on e in we but only I. And only I am the saviour of this world."

█████████ 02.18.2008 12:20 PM

why dont you just buy a puppet? you would control it better.

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ✌➬
Yes it is healthy be selfish. Repeat, "It is only me, there is on e in we but only I. And only I am the saviour of this world."


being "the saviour of this world" is not selfish.

get your story straight

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by █████████
why dont you just buy a puppet? you would control it better.


you can't control a cat, tarado. you basically work for him. but there are rewards.

✌➬ 02.18.2008 12:23 PM

Damn you, I was trying to go for the ego boost angle. What a party pooper.

 

█████████ 02.18.2008 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
you can't control a cat, tarado. you basically work for him. but there are rewards.

the cloned cat is going to act differently, fool.

!@#$%! 02.18.2008 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by █████████
the cloned cat is going to act differently, fool.


oy, bestia, yes, he will act differently but not so differently, any cat will act differently, but this one less than others, and that's good enough for me-- in any case you can't freeze time & every moment is unique and unrepeatable and that is why i am going to quit arguing this and go eat pancakes now.

█████████ 02.18.2008 12:43 PM

thing is, nothing can garantee you the cat will act not so differently.

nicfit 02.18.2008 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nicfit
 

autoquote

tesla69 02.20.2008 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EyeballGrowth
The only people who are against cloning are religious. They are against it because they don't want proof that humans can create other humans. Only God can do that.

There is nothing wrong with cloning. It can have lifesaving benefits. Read about it sometime


So if I want to clone your mother for a sex slave you think that is morally ok? Actually, I'm going to clone 3 or 4 of her and keep them all tied up until I need them. Since they're just clones and not really humans and its not really your mother so you wouldn't care I guess. I might video tape it though to sell on the internet - or just give it away - but there's nothing wrong with that I guess.

Rob Instigator 02.20.2008 12:22 PM

I think there is nothing un ethical about it at all.

cloning a dog would create a brand new dog, like a twin of the other dog. it would be a puppy, you;'d love it and raise it and it would turn out different from the previous dog.

cloning is fucking awesome and I would do it for my dead kitty kat isabella if I knew where her body was.

cloning rules all.

many animals reproduce by cloning instead of sexual gene sharing, and nature digs it, why shouold humans and other animals not have that option?

clone away!

Rob Instigator 02.20.2008 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tesla69
So if I want to clone your mother for a sex slave you think that is morally ok? Actually, I'm going to clone 3 or 4 of her and keep them all tied up until I need them. Since they're just clones and not really humans and its not really your mother so you wouldn't care I guess. I might video tape it though to sell on the internet - or just give it away - but there's nothing wrong with that I guess.


this is STUPID

if you clone a human it will take just as long for that clone to become adult as a regular baby. your argument is dumb as FUCK
by the time your "mopther" was old enough to fuck you would be 18 years older and maybe dead.

shit

people watch too many movies where clones are "rapidly grown"

dumb!!!!!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:38 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth