"Ranaldo" is misspelled.

Ostensibly, he was trying to allude to the fact that Lee only has one song on the record. Use of the word "overshadowed" is not exactly the best way to make his point.

Lee is still present in the songs, but I do get the sense that Lee's work on the album, besides the one song he contributed, he really is rather overshadowed. I was expecting a little more out of him. On "Do You Believe in Rapture", the guitar noise that is coming from Lee's guitar is mixed a little too low. It should have been a little bit louder. The album has this toned down feeling through some of it that just doesnt seem to work all the time.

Yes Atari...that point has been brought up. I didn't write the review. Only quoting him...


It is a poor choice of words. I think I'll mail him a thesaurus.

kill all the staff writers!!!!!!!!!! thats so stupid,,,he wanted to be writing something bout the white stripes or strokes,,i think he knows better about them

If he doesn't want emails bashing his poor writing then he shouldn't have put his email addy on the review.

Patrick Dolan is a nerf herder

But is he scruffy-looking?

Well, he is right, the album sucks.

But yeah.. Kim Deal, haha..

give him a break, no way!!! inaccuracy is one of the major crimes of journalism. his review is misinformed and completely poorly written. email sent, politely stating his inaccuracys!

^^^EXACTLY^^^^^^^^^^^