I dont know if a 7.7 is good in pitchfork's book (i dont usually go to that site) but the review seemed overall pretty positive.

Ah the indie website reaction to a Pitchfork review. Isnt this a bit old hat? A bit like an indie version of Pop Idol? And Pitchfork is Simon Cowell.

i love pitchfork, personally. i get a kick out of pretentious rock reviews.