Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   The Smiths....are good? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=37792)

batreleaser 01.25.2010 05:26 PM

why the fuck are deftones getting compared to the smiths? not to say they didnt have some cool songs and riffs, they sure as shit did. "pink maggot" was boss.

Torn Curtain 01.25.2010 05:43 PM

Not all Morrissey solo stuff is bad, Vauxhall & I is great (but I'll grant you that none of his other records are any near as good).

the ikara cult 01.25.2010 06:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by batreleaser
why the fuck are deftones getting compared to the smiths? not to say they didnt have some cool songs and riffs, they sure as shit did. "pink maggot" was boss.


deftones were a triffic band, great tunes.

the ikara cult 01.25.2010 06:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
exactly!!! I also have to accept that my favorite lyricist (Chino from deftones) took much of his style from Morissey.. I like Chino's version better, plus if Smiths were as heavy as deftones i might be able to get into them but I abhor 80s sound unless its roots reggae ;)


Chino is your favourite lyricist?
Thats collossaly shit mate

Pax Americana 01.25.2010 08:11 PM

Love the Smiths. Can't help it. I think it's mostly Johnny Marr that does it for me. That guy has a language all his own on the guitar. He's truely a unique player.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 01.25.2010 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the ikara cult
Chino is your favourite lyricist?
Thats collossaly shit mate


yes, for me its not simply the content of the lyrics, but the delivery. for me, the lyrics have a content which truly reflects my feelings/thoughts/experiences and I have an affinity with the sound/style of the singing.I imagine this is why folks like the Smiths or sonic youth or blink 182 or any band of any genre for that matter..

its all a matter of taste isn't it?

Quote:

Originally Posted by batreleaser
why the fuck are deftones getting compared to the smiths? not to say they didnt have some cool songs and riffs, they sure as shit did. "pink maggot" was boss.



Chino says that morissey is his biggest influence, and it is on all his playlists for years and years now, clearly he digs em. where as deftones are one of my biggest influences and are on my constant playlists but I can't stand morissey.. its textbook irony i say.. like preferring british blues to chicago style you know?

atsonicpark 01.26.2010 12:37 AM

Greatest lyricist ever? Mark E. Smith, Don Van Vliet..

Don't give a shit about Moz's lyrics.

SuperCreep 01.26.2010 01:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
(in most every song he is either making fun of someone or making fun of himself. too many people read just the surface of his lyrics and think he is just a whiney bitch)

well put. i honestly find that smiths songs (more often than not) are in good humor. even the depressing stuff like suffer little children, please please please let me get what i want, asleep, etc. are EXTREMELY well-written tunes and don't come across as the slightest bit whiney to me.

i think i might have said it before on here, but people need to stop taking the mozzer so seriously.

demonrail666 01.26.2010 07:04 AM

i agree. for such a supposedly miserable band The smiths created some of the most hilarious music I've heard. I remember trying to stop myself from laughing out loud while listening to 'Rusholme Ruffians' on my walkman on the bus when i was a kid - a problem I never had while listenig to, say, Joy Division. The Smiths were 'miserable' in the same way a Mike Leigh film or an Alan Bennet play might also be considered miserable.

Genteel Death 01.26.2010 01:16 PM

Does it really matter in 2010?

loubarret 01.26.2010 01:36 PM

Yes it does as much as the sunset city girls where to this site.

dazedcola 01.30.2010 12:47 PM

So I got the Louder Than Bombs comp and I love it.I kept repeating songs so much it took hours to finish the first listen. I kinda feel like this band is the british rem except they're a little more punk and can be a little sadder. Morissey can really write some good lyrics though while they can occasionoally be cringeworthy and that Marr has really inspired me on the guitar.Learned to play Sheila take a bow as soon as i got home yesterday.

So what would you guys reccomend next?

Torn Curtain 01.30.2010 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dazedcola
So what would you guys reccomend next?


Hatful of hollow, followed by S/T, the Queen is dead and Strangeways, here we come.

loubarret 01.30.2010 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Torn Curtain
Hatful of hollow, followed by S/T, the Queen is dead and Strangeways, here we come.

Look out with strangeways, it has a weird a bit plastic production. Some people hate the album for that, some love it for that.

Rob Instigator 02.01.2010 10:09 AM

strangeways is fucking aw3esome though, what with Stop Me If You;ve Heard This One Before.......

ricechex 02.01.2010 10:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
strangeways is fucking aw3esome though, what with Stop Me If You;ve Heard This One Before.......


Yes, Strangeways is great! I like em all, but that one seems to be underrated a nut. While they all sound great, that one may sound the best, purely sound wise.

demonrail666 02.01.2010 10:26 AM

I've never been particularly into Strangeways - although I do think the track 'Paint a Vulgar Picture' boasts some of Marr's best playing. On the whole though i don't think it quite lives up to The Smiths' middle two studio LPs: Meat is Murder and The Queen is Dead. To me, Strangeways sounds like an album made by a band in the process of splitting up. It has a certain gloominess and self obsession (lots of references to the band itself within a number of songs - not least 'Stop Me If You think that You've Heard this One Before' and the aforementioned 'Paint a Vulgar Picture'). In that sense it's interesting in terms of the band's own history but lacks the broader appeal of their earlier albums. For me, the band's creative peak came with The Queen is Dead.

Derek 02.01.2010 12:24 PM

Strangeways is my favourite Smiths album.

loubarret 02.01.2010 12:55 PM

mine is selftiteld or louder then bombs

auto-aim 02.01.2010 10:06 PM

I got the queen is dead. never got into it and never pursued it furrther


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth