Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   CD vs Vinyl (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=13537)

uhler 03.10.2009 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
and the whole thing of obsessive care of vinyl is kind of the point. Vinyl colectors nowawdays are archivists really, unlike people in the old days wh bought records and listened to them and treated them as shittily as people nowadays treat CD's. (playing them with an ancient crusty needle, stacking up 7" singles or records without their sleeves, throwing them around, etc.)

I treat my vinyl recordss like bits of archeology. I take great care with them, keep them from direct sun, no heat, no humidity. I never stack them, only have them on their sides on shelves. I woul do the same for old books, or artworks.
CD's however, I could care less, and a digital file that can get completely erased if you happen to walk by a powerful electromagnet? shiiiiiiiit.


yeah i do the same, but i do the same with cds too. i try to keep all of my cds in great shape. even though i tend to drop the cases from time to time. i just try to keep everything i own in great shape though.

Rob Instigator 03.10.2009 03:31 PM

I love how so many CD manufacturers are now selling them in paper/cardboard sleeves. the "jewel case" is such a fucking joke.

MellySingsDoom 03.10.2009 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
I love browsing.

plus the smell. I love the smell of records and books.

I could live in a tiny place as long as my books and records were there.


This is after my own heart too :)

I tend to buy more CDs than vinyl (due to availability of stuff - ie. many releases I buy are CD-only, alas), but I do loves me still a decent vinyl release. If nothing else, the artwork on vinyl kills that of CDs everytime, I think.

On the vinyl fidelity point, I've bought some vinyl whose pressing quality is staggeringly crap (I'm thinking here in particular of some of those ESP-Disk vinyls bootlegged by Base Records), and vinyl which sounds so fucking good it's incredible...mind you, I've never been insane/dedicated enough to buy a lathe-cut records. This will piss off some people, I know, but I do contend that the CD format is actually pretty spot on for some musics (classical, power electronics, "drone" being some examples that come to mind). What do others think on this point?

chairman of the bored 03.10.2009 05:36 PM

^ i agree with drone/power electronics and i'd add ambient to that list of things i prefer on cd. basically because of the long form style of these types of music. it kills the vibe to have a fade out at the end of one side, flip it and resume droning away. i bought earth 2 on vinyl like an idiot and that was my lesson.

Toilet & Bowels 03.10.2009 06:40 PM

mp3s sound like crap, CDs are flimsy and degrade naturally over time, tapes get chewed up and worn out, vinyl can't be played in a walkman or a car and is generally a hassle.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 03.10.2009 06:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
mp3s sound like crap, CDs are flimsy and degrade naturally over time, tapes get chewed up and worn out, vinyl can't be played in a walkman or a car and is generally a hassle.


and live musicians don't fit in your pocket, it sounds like you prefer fundamentalist islamic music (ie, none at all)

Toilet & Bowels 03.10.2009 06:47 PM

all formats are rubbish, use whichever suits the occasion best and bloody get on with it

terminal pharmacy 03.10.2009 07:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MellySingsDoom
This will piss off some people, I know, but I do contend that the CD format is actually pretty spot on for some musics (classical, power electronics, "drone" being some examples that come to mind). What do others think on this point?


I would definately leave classical off of that list. Current digital recording technologies do not have large enough sampling rates to enable the full range of frequency harmonics to make it onto the recordings. I'm talking frequencies we can't hear with our ears, however these harmonics do effect the frequencies in the human hearing range. CD's and other digital media are not able as of yet to produce this quality that analog systems can. Sony are coming close with their newer digital recording formats with a 2.4 ghz sampling rate, however this is incredibly expensinve and hardly any studios have taken it up.

gmku 03.10.2009 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
all formats are rubbish, use whichever suits the occasion best and bloody get on with it


Oh bloody blokin' limey hell, wot.

SYRFox 03.11.2009 01:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
mp3s sound like crap, CDs are flimsy and degrade naturally over time, tapes get chewed up and worn out, vinyl can't be played in a walkman or a car and is generally a hassle.

Hurrah 8-track!!

phoenix 03.11.2009 07:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by terminal pharmacy
I would definately leave classical off of that list. Current digital recording technologies do not have large enough sampling rates to enable the full range of frequency harmonics to make it onto the recordings. I'm talking frequencies we can't hear with our ears, however these harmonics do effect the frequencies in the human hearing range. CD's and other digital media are not able as of yet to produce this quality that analog systems can. Sony are coming close with their newer digital recording formats with a 2.4 ghz sampling rate, however this is incredibly expensinve and hardly any studios have taken it up.


sexy post.

sarramkrop 03.11.2009 07:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmku
Oh bloody blokin' limey hell, wot.


I need to teach you how to insult those english more effectively.

gmku 03.11.2009 08:04 AM

Please.

greedrex 03.11.2009 08:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
all formats are rubbish, use whichever suits the occasion best and bloody get on with it

he he:D

Glice 03.11.2009 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
I need to teach you how to insult those english more effectively.


"Please Hitler, please continuing raping me in front of my darling Vespa. Mamma Mia I've got a problem with organised crime and no morals about fucking EVERYTHING".

This post brought to you by the international centre for national stereotypes (i.e., my house).

sarramkrop 03.11.2009 02:12 PM

Sure you make a big fuss about war issues, considering that if it wasn't for the yanks saving your ASS like anyone with a knowledge of history could tell, you wouldn't even have the time in the world to think about national stereotypes. Erm, back to snogging children outside the school now, you need to catch up on modern day morality.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 03.11.2009 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
I need to teach you how to insult those english more effectively.


Select your translation method.
Translate From... English to Chinese English to Dutch English to French English to German English to Italian English to Japanese English to Korean English to Portuguese English to Russian English to Spanish Chinese to English Dutch to English French to English German to English Italian to English Japanese to English Korean to English Portuguese to English Russian to English Spanish to English

Localization:
American English
British English

Glice 03.11.2009 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Sure you make a big fuss about war issues, considering that if it wasn't for the yanks saving your ASS like anyone with a knowledge of history could tell, you wouldn't even have the time in the world to think about national stereotypes. Erm, back to snogging children outside the school now, you need to catch up on modern day morality.


Defending the Johnny-come-latelys? Unspurprising, given your lot seemed to invent the idea of it actually being an insult to ask for food to be delivered within 6 or 7 hours.

Toilet & Bowels 03.11.2009 08:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Defending the Johnny-come-latelys? Unspurprising, given your lot seemed to invent the idea of it actually being an insult to ask for food to be delivered within 6 or 7 hours.


Funny that an Italian would bring up WWII
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Compass

sarramkrop 03.12.2009 02:23 AM

I think it's not funny at all. I find it more funny that an English generally makes it sound like England won the war by themselves, when if it's obvious you haven't. You would have never been able to, even though you go on about it like that's the case.
Being YOU who say that, it's not surprising. Also, wasn't Glice the one who made references to war issues first? Toilet & Bowels feeling a bit touchy-feely?

Toilet & Bowels 03.12.2009 07:52 AM

now now, there's no need for being a sore loser

sarramkrop 03.12.2009 09:32 AM

Did you look at yourself in the mirror when you wrote that? I'm afraid for you, I'm not sore about anything. It does sound like someone is especially deluded when the phenomenon i described above happens, though. Maybe I should put it down to one pint too many and sudden memory loss....who knows? Lulu? Lala?

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 03.12.2009 12:33 PM

are you guys seriously arguing over WWII?

Everybody lost that shit except for the damned Antichrist, who took over the world in the ashes. WWII thoroughly destroyed all the remnants of our ancient civilizations and cultures, a process which WWI began, and resulted in all this bleak post-modernism. We replaced imperial colonialism with imperial globalization, we replaced the religious wars with the cold war, and now we have a confusing mess where the remaining old world cultures (ie, Islam and rural Africa) are in a kind of pitched battle against the New World Order..

It is petty to argue over that war, we all lost :(

frades 05.05.2009 04:21 AM

here is a song to turntables : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cCfzCxEw9P0

there are not so many to tapes, can anyone give some?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth