Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   whats the worst album? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=30834)

Rob Instigator 04.30.2009 09:05 AM

love My Friend GOO

and how it ends.

Love panty lies toooo

mysonichaircut 04.30.2009 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by greedrex
^nope


i followed your links and found out that you are selling records with a cc license. interesting - but how does it work, i mean - buy AND cc-license? Does it mean, i buy one cd, and then i am allowed to share it, reissue it or whatever for free?

SuperCreep 04.30.2009 09:25 AM

Probably the s/t or RR, but I still like 'em. I don't know. "Worst" and "Sonic Youth" don't usually appear in the same sentence for me.

candymoan 04.30.2009 09:26 AM

not too keen on EJST&NS or NYG&F...
but also have the ability to thoroughly enjoy any SY tune...

noisereductions 04.30.2009 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZEROpumpkins
One day you will all grow up and put RR in perspective instead of hating it just because it's a recent SY release.

News flash:
Most fans hate the most recent release by an artist the most. They become so familiar with their older material, they set unrealistic expectations which cannot possibly be met. It's how the human mind works.



I dnt totally agree. But I do agree. I think a lot of fans will get more into RR down the road. I've never really understood the hate it gets. It has some really great songs. Some good ones. A couple of meh ones. It's not like a beginning-to-end-shit fest. Plus, like I always have to throw in: "Reena" is one of the best songs of the 00's.

Anyway, I can't really think of a "worst album." If pressed, I'd probably say SYR6 is my least favorite. But there's a time & place for each of their releases where it will make me happy.

noisereductions 04.30.2009 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
love My Friend GOO

and how it ends.

Love panty lies toooo



"Panty Lies" rules. But "My Friend Goo" is definitely their worst song. Ever.

alex_could 04.30.2009 09:50 AM

(what's the worst album?) to my mind The Eternal is

thesilverrocket 04.30.2009 10:51 AM

This thread kills me. For me, this question is akin to 'Which finger would you rather have chopped off in an industrial accident?"

transmogrifier 04.30.2009 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alex_could
(what's the worst album?) to my mind The Eternal is


Your mind has steered you wrong.

alex_could 04.30.2009 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by transmogrifier
Your mind has steered you wrong.


I was waitin' for YOU saying it!

transmogrifier 04.30.2009 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alex_could
I was waitin' for YOU saying it!


Rather Ripped is probably their weakest album to date, but that's a relative term.

automatic bzooty 04.30.2009 06:48 PM

I reckon Nurse is my least listened to, but it is by no means a bad album.

Sonic Youth 37 04.30.2009 06:49 PM

In The Fishtank

Jeremy 04.30.2009 06:57 PM

If we're really counting everything then I think the Whitey Album is also beyond horrible. Another idea that sounded good to them but came off poorly.

~Jeremy~

joe11121 04.30.2009 07:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeremy
If we're really counting everything then I think the Whitey Album is also beyond horrible. Another idea that sounded good to them but came off poorly.

~Jeremy~


The Whitey Album has some great tracks on it, especially MacBeth.

Jeremy 04.30.2009 07:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe11121
The Whitey Album has some great tracks on it, especially MacBeth.


I personally just don't really enjoy it. Always makes me want to listen to something else from them.

~Jeremy~

Theremin 04.30.2009 07:13 PM

Dirty I guess. Though a 1000 leaves always leave me with mixed feelings as well.

duderanchnurse 04.30.2009 08:54 PM

Worst albums
1- Rather Ripped
2- Murray Street
3- EJSTANS

They remain great albums though

duderanchnurse 04.30.2009 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noisereductions
"Panty Lies" rules. But "My Friend Goo" is definitely their worst song. Ever.


booooooo i love it!

worst songs are definitely What A Waste, Lights Out and Sleepin Around (the ones that kill RR)

Death & the Maiden 04.30.2009 09:07 PM

I think their worst songs are Mary-Christ and Cinderella's Big Score.

mysonichaircut 05.01.2009 05:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Death & the Maiden
I think their worst songs are Mary-Christ and Cinderella's Big Score.


Mary christ is one of my favorite.

Death & the Maiden 05.01.2009 06:35 AM

I just find it unbelievably annoying, and when I think about, it gets stuck in my head and won't leave.

Death & the Maiden 05.01.2009 06:52 AM

I just listened to Jet Set for the first time in ages (actually it's the first SY album in awhile), and I actually quite liked it. Well, except for Thurston's tracks, I find those to be as bad as I remembered them.

al shabbray 05.01.2009 07:44 AM

for me its rather ripped, too.
there are some moments, but way less then on every other record of the youth. my itunes says I am right, too.

Torn Curtain 05.01.2009 03:33 PM

Rather ripped.

PAULYBEE2656 05.01.2009 03:35 PM

experimental jet set followed by rather ripped followed by something damn good.

mysonichaircut 05.01.2009 04:39 PM

i dont understand u guys. many of you seem to dislike ejs. i cant decide whether ejs, ddn, washing mashine, goo, sister, evol, atl, nycg is better. to me, nycgf is a little more "inventive" or something than the others, but ejs is the same league as sister, ddn and so on.

Derek 05.01.2009 05:07 PM

The songs sound like they were written in 10 minutes almost.

Jeremy 05.01.2009 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mysonichaircut
but ejs is the same league as sister, ddn and so on.


The fuck? You're honestly going to compare such works of excellence like Candle, Schizophrenia, Rain King, The Sprawl, Silver Rocket, Catholic Block, Cotton Crown, etc to such shits Tokyo Eye? Quest For The Cup? Skink? Sweet Shine, among the rest of the album?

Damn if that isn't the craziest thing I've heard all day.

~Jeremy~

greedrex 05.02.2009 06:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mysonichaircut
ejs is the same league as sister, ddn and so on.

yeah it's a bit far-fetched.....
i love EJS though.

sarramkrop 05.02.2009 06:53 AM

There's nothing not to love about any of their records up to Murray Street, even if you take personal taste into account. Sonic Nurse has one great song (Golden Blue), and Rather Ripped brings back bad memories and a lot of sadness. Reene is a good song, but it's not enough.

armidasr 05.02.2009 11:26 AM

silver session ???

greedrex 05.02.2009 12:22 PM

asp! come back silversessionbasheralert!

PAULYBEE2656 05.02.2009 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by armidasr
silver session ???


thats possibly their best release ... not on face value but the whole deal and thinking around the record is fantastic..silver sessions should be reduxed, rereleased and rammed down everybodys throat under the threat of gunshot... fantastic record......

end rant!

joe11121 05.02.2009 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by armidasr
silver session ???


Silver Sessions is amazing

mysonichaircut 05.03.2009 04:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeremy
The fuck? You're honestly going to compare such works of excellence like Candle, Schizophrenia, Rain King, The Sprawl, Silver Rocket, Catholic Block, Cotton Crown, etc to such shits Tokyo Eye? Quest For The Cup? Skink? Sweet Shine, among the rest of the album?

Damn if that isn't the craziest thing I've heard all day.

~Jeremy~


right. especially Tokyo Eye and Skink. they are brilliant.

Trasher02 05.03.2009 04:38 PM

RR followed by Dirty.
I don't think they're horrid albums they're just my least favourite albums.

reginald 05.04.2009 06:17 PM

As much as I LOVE the music, I think the PRODUCTION of Sister leaves something to be desired. It's thin. So is EVOL, for the most part, to me. I hope SY remasters these and gets the UMMMPHHHH I like put into these albums. Other than that, I can't say I don't like any of their releases as far as music. I even LOVE Rather Ripped for it's more poppy and simple aspect.

Skuj 05.04.2009 10:09 PM

WHY OH WHY DO SO MANY "SONIC YOUTH FANS" DISLIKE RATHER RIPPED???

I just don't understand the lack of love for this extremely solid album. ***Shakes head and both fists at the non-believers.***

Skuj 05.04.2009 10:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
Dirty fucking rules. chappel hill, wish fulfilment, JC, PURR, 100%, the record is awesome.


the worst SY record is Experimenta Jet Set Trash & No Star by A MILE


Yeah...Dirty is fucking Ace, you people! I don't know, maybe I'm older than most of you (47), but when Dirty came out in 92, it was fucking WORSHIPPED. And it deserved the worship.

I think EJST+NS is the most underappreciated SY album.

Damn, this is a tough question....the "worst" SY album? It will still be a "good" album in my books.....ok.....Goo never really did a whole lot for me.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth