Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Pitchfork: The top 500 tracks of the decade (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=33823)

SYRFox 08.22.2009 03:46 AM

Also, as others have said on this thread, and as I've already said many times, I see no problem with Pitchfork and I read it quite often

Death & the Maiden 08.22.2009 05:43 AM

If you claim to hate Pitchfork, but you still discuss it, it is obvious you are an avid reader.

Glice 08.22.2009 06:19 AM

486. Spiller [ft. Sophie Ellis-Bextor]
"Groovejet (If This Ain't Love)"
[Positiva; 2000]

489. Kano
"Reload It"
[679; 2005]

483. Platinum 45 [ft. More Fire Crew]
"Oi!"
[Go! Beat/FTL; 2002]


476. Ward 21
"Petrol"
[Greensleeves; 2003]

466. Saint Etienne
"How We Used to Live"
[Mantra; 2000]

451. Scissor Sisters
"Mary"
[Polydor; 2004]

445. Ricardo Villalobos
"Que Belle Epoque"
[Frisbee Tracks; 2000]

438. Lady Sovereign
"Ch-Ching (Cheque 1, 2 Remix)"
[Chocolate Industries; 2005]

432. Sugababes
"Overload"
[London/Warner; 2000]

423. The Delgados
"All You Need Is Hate"
[Mantra; 2003]

422. Santogold
"Lights Out"
[Downtown; 2008]

Ok, I'm bored of that game now. This seems like a pretty good list to me. I would suggest that a lot of you have shit for ears if you don't think Umbrella or Missy or whatever are utterly astonishing singles. RnB might turn out legions of shite (I'm thinking early-90s Boys2Men or RKelly) but when it's on it blows most other things out of the water.

Also, a lot of you go for albums rather than singles, which is an entirely different thing. I wouldn't say that SY, for instance, have had a genuinely great single since Dirty, but they've had a few great albums since then.

Glice 08.22.2009 06:20 AM

I'm still going through this list -

394. The Streets
"Blinded by the Lights"
[679/Warner; 2004]

Would be a top tenner for me.

sarramkrop 08.22.2009 06:24 AM

Most of those songs couldn't stand a chance when it came to universal agreement. Parochial crap made ''some'' good. I like that.

Toilet & Bowels 08.22.2009 07:01 AM

do the people who wrote that list listen to anything outside the top 40?

Toilet & Bowels 08.22.2009 07:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pinkstation
YES!!!!!
along with the 18-part music video.


it's 22 part, and there are 10 more coming out at the end of this year, i can't wait

demonrail666 08.22.2009 07:20 AM

it's struck me reading through the list that I've listened to next to no new music this decade, and what new stuff i have listened to is apparently shit.

nicfit 08.22.2009 08:03 AM

there are some really nice picks (mainly in the more "pop" department) in there, but, as with every superlong list, basically, I think it's a bit pointless and lacking... I'd have thrown in some Black Heart Procession. some cLOUDDEAD, Why?, lots of stuff..so, yeh, big deal, uh?
pop rocks.

noisereductions 08.22.2009 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
I'm still going through this list -

394. The Streets
"Blinded by the Lights"
[679/Warner; 2004]

Would be a top tenner for me.


snore.

jimbrim 08.22.2009 10:03 AM

40. The Avalanches
"Since I Left You"
[Modular/XL; 2000]


I totally forgot about this track, I haven't heard it in years. Great tune.

dirty bunny 08.22.2009 01:03 PM

I think I posted in here already. But I just wanted to say kudos to Pitchfork for making this list. But I have some issues with it.

The first half of the list, the lower-down part, I recognized a lot of songs I hadn't heard in a while. So that made me smile. But the closer I got to the top half of the list, the fewer songs I'd heard.

Question: why is LCD Soundsystem and Hot Chip featured so prominently, particularly in the top half? I've barely even heard of the former, and what I've heard of the latter has left me completely unimpressed. The lads at pitchfork obviously have a yen for synth pop. And I'm not sure that Daft Punk even got a couple songs. Weird. And another thing: there's one track that's a mash-up of a Strokes song with Christina Arugala's "Genie In A Bottle" (one of the most cringe-inducing attempts at a pop song) that's ranked like #148 or something. The mind boggles.

At the end of it all though, I'm left thinking if this is the best of the singles of this decade, what a shit decade this has been.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 08.22.2009 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
pitchfork has not-so-gradually descended into a gofddamn fucking folk pussy fuck singer songwriter asssucking weepy bulshit acoustic loving baby soft WUSS rock a la taylor and John Denver and all that same goddamn horrible lukewarm cringe inducing shithead 70's rehash nonsense. FUCK ALL THAT SHIT.


FUCK I HATE IT SO FUCKING BAD. such pussy pampered fucks strumming their goddamn folkie good for nothing garbage. burn them all to the ground goddamnit!


Fuck yeah!!!

Repped!

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 08.22.2009 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Death & the Maiden
If you claim to hate Pitchfork, but you still discuss it, it is obvious you are an avid reader.


I only really take a look when people post links

TheFoxBen 08.22.2009 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirty bunny
I think I posted in here already. But I just wanted to say kudos to Pitchfork for making this list. But I have some issues with it.

The first half of the list, the lower-down part, I recognized a lot of songs I hadn't heard in a while. So that made me smile. But the closer I got to the top half of the list, the fewer songs I'd heard.

Question: why is LCD Soundsystem and Hot Chip featured so prominently, particularly in the top half? I've barely even heard of the former, and what I've heard of the latter has left me completely unimpressed. The lads at pitchfork obviously have a yen for synth pop. And I'm not sure that Daft Punk even got a couple songs. Weird. And another thing: there's one track that's a mash-up of a Strokes song with Christina Arugala's "Genie In A Bottle" (one of the most cringe-inducing attempts at a pop song) that's ranked like #148 or something. The mind boggles.

At the end of it all though, I'm left thinking if this is the best of the singles of this decade, what a shit decade this has been.


Well, LCD Soundsystem is featured so prominently because it is good, I wouldn't put "All My Friends" as the second greatest song of the decade but it's a great song, so is "Someone Great".

And,

139. Daft Punk
"Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger"
[Virgin; 2001]


23. Daft Punk
"Digital Love"
[Virgin; 2001]


5. Daft Punk
"One More Time"
[Virgin; 2000]



But you're right about that Strokes/Aguilera mash-up song, I think it's terrible. They should have put "Hard to Explain" alone.

pinkstation 08.22.2009 01:32 PM

the strokes hype killed me. on the cover of rolling stone with the headliner of "ARE THEY THE SAVIORS OF ROCK AND ROLL?"

fuck you. there are really REALLY good bands around now if you just open your fucking eyes.

dirty bunny 08.22.2009 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheFoxBen
Well, LCD Soundsystem is featured so prominently because it is good, I wouldn't put "All My Friends" as the second greatest song of the decade but it's a great song, so is "Someone Great".

And,

139. Daft Punk
"Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger"
[Virgin; 2001]


23. Daft Punk
"Digital Love"
[Virgin; 2001]


5. Daft Punk
"One More Time"
[Virgin; 2000]



But you're right about that Strokes/Aguilera mash-up song, I think it's terrible. They should have put "Hard to Explain" alone.


Ah well, can't be right all the time I guess :P

Decayed Rhapsody 08.22.2009 01:40 PM

James Murphy is an insufferable cunt.

jerf 08.22.2009 02:08 PM

500 tracks, and not one Mars Volta song? For shame, Pitchfork...

GeneticKiss 08.22.2009 03:24 PM

My top ten tracks of the decade, in no order:

1. Mastodon: "Oblivion"
2. Daft Punk: "Aerodynamic"
3. Transplants: "Diamonds and Guns"
4. Gorillaz: "Feel Good Inc."
5. A Perfect Circle: "3 Libras"
6. The Vines: "Outtathaway"
7. Massive Attack: "Future Proof"
8. Deftones: "Beware"
9. The Cure: "Alt.End"
10. Minus The Bear: "Knights"

I didn't pick any SY becuase I couldn't decide on 1 song.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth