Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Ranking all Sleater Kinney albums and side projects (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=113151)

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.17.2016 06:16 PM

Ranking all Sleater Kinney albums and side projects
 
1. The Hot Rock
2. Dig Me Out
3. One Beat
4. No Cities To Love
5. The Woods
6. Kill My blues
7. Wild Flag
8. All hands on the bad one
9. Such Friends Are Dangerous
10. Call the Doctor
11. 1000 Years
12. Age of Backwards
13. Sleater-Kinney
14. Excuse 17
15. Introducing Cadallaca
16. Calculated
17. Out West
18. Quasi records (sorry I'm just not into them enough to have all their albums but i definitely enjoyed their stage shows)
19. These Monsters Are Real
20. Heartless Marvin demo

Kuhb 02.18.2016 12:33 AM

I loved the Wild Flag album. Just effin' great rock music. I'd put it ahead of all the SK albums except One Beat and No Cities to Love, which are perfect. The Woods close behind.

Severian 02.18.2016 06:48 PM

The Hot Rock is an interesting choice for #1... not what I would have expected. But it's got some of their best tracks, for sure.

I don't have the patience or memory to list all that shot out. I haven't even heard some of those albums. But my favorite S-K albums are Dig Me Out, The Hot Rock and .... actually, I'd probably have to put No Cities To Love at #3 at the moment.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.18.2016 06:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Severian
The Hot Rock is an interesting choice for #1... not what I would have expected. But it's got some of their best tracks, for sure.


From a music critic perspective The Hot Rock is definitely not their best album, but from my own personal perspective its not just my fav SK related record, its in my top 5 ALL TIME for any record by any band!

Quote:

I don't have the patience or memory to list all that shot out. I haven't even heard some of those albums. But my favorite S-K albums are Dig Me Out, The Hot Rock and .... actually, I'd probably have to put No Cities To Love at #3 at the moment.
good that was kind of the point, to expand peoples horizons. Indeed if included the Quasi records list would be over 25

Severian 02.18.2016 07:30 PM

I like Quasi. Never really went all out for Wild Flag like a lot of folks did, but they definitely made some good rock in an era when not a lot of good rock was coming out (not unlike now). Loved, loved loved the Corin Tucker Band.

But there are a few titles on this list I need to check out.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.18.2016 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Severian
I like Quasi. Never really went all out for Wild Flag like a lot of folks did, but they definitely made some good rock in an era when not a lot of good rock was coming out (not unlike now). Loved, loved loved the Corin Tucker Band.

But there are a few titles on this list I need to check out.

Wild Flag was a much superior stage show than the album.. indeed when i saw them they hadn't even recorded or leaked anything and it was only their 2nd show ever so it was a total surprise and a kick ass one at that

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.18.2016 07:51 PM

Also i think Kill My Blues might honestly be some of Corin's best work ever i am just too attached to SK records to rank it above them but

Severian 02.18.2016 09:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
Wild Flag was a much superior stage show than the album.. indeed when i saw them they hadn't even recorded or leaked anything and it was only their 2nd show ever so it was a total surprise and a kick ass one at that


Hey that's exactly what I was going to say. Except it's been so long since I heard the album that I was worried I wasn't remember things accurately.
But yes, that was my impression too. Wild Flag live was really something to behold. Saw them only once, but one of the best rock shows I've ever seen.

I was surprised because I was an SK live nut, and really only saw WF because of their association. But they were surprisingly balls out powerful.

Kinda like seeing Viet Cong because, y'know, Women was seminal, and being astonished that they actually kick all holy ass.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.18.2016 09:57 PM

During the SK hiatus Wild Flag shows were my fix.. and i agree that they were a FORCE.
Have you seen Ex Hex? Mary was so timid in Wild Flag her solo shows that i was blown away at how kick ass and outgoing she is in Ex Hex

Kuhb 02.19.2016 02:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
During the SK hiatus Wild Flag shows were my fix.. and i agree that they were a FORCE.
Have you seen Ex Hex? Mary was so timid in Wild Flag her solo shows that i was blown away at how kick ass and outgoing she is in Ex Hex


Have you heard her 2005 solo album, also called Ex Hex? I love it, as well as the followup The Shapes We Make. Fantastic guitar playing

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 02:05 AM

Yes i saw her on that tour too! But nothing she has ever done is as gregarious as the band Ex Hex..

Kuhb 02.19.2016 02:06 AM

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VOCKOFY3E1s

This song rules

Kuhb 02.19.2016 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
Yes i saw her on that tour too! But nothing she has ever done is as gregarious as the band Ex Hex..


Oh man that would have been great.

Toilet & Bowels 02.19.2016 08:24 AM

1. The Hot Rock
2. Quasi - Featuring Birds
3. The Spells - Age of Backwards
4. Quasi - Field Studies
5. Heavens to Betsy & Excuse 17
6. Screw the rest, maybe not Call the Doctor, but that's about it.

noisereductions 02.19.2016 09:25 AM

man I used to love Quasi. Haven't really listened to em in years. But I thought they were great.

Also, I really loved All Hands On The Bad One.

Screaming Skull 02.19.2016 10:19 AM

Here's a fun list with links...SK's 10 best cover songs...

http://www.stereogum.com/1853708/sle...s/best-covers/

Rob Instigator 02.19.2016 10:38 AM

Spells is just a 7"!!! I love it too

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 11:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
1. The Hot Rock
2. Quasi - Featuring Birds
3. The Spells - Age of Backwards
4. Quasi - Field Studies
5. Heavens to Betsy & Excuse 17
6. Screw the rest, maybe not Call the Doctor, but that's about it.


I love this list! By the way, you got the full EP version of Age of Backwards from me yes? I uploaded it and posted here a few years ago but I saved the four extra tracks that Carrie released via her NPR blog back in 2009.. indeed releasing those was the process that created Wild Flag!!

PM is you don't have those other four songs I will send them to you mos def

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
Spells is just a 7"!!! I love it too


Same as T&B, PM me if you don't have the other four tracks which make it an EP rather than an maxi-single

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noisereductions

Also, I really loved All Hands On The Bad One.


Man that was just such a fun record! I think of all their records this is the most straight up fun record, its not too serious even while it has some serious tracks. It feels like a "no pressure" record of tunes they just wanted to put out!

I mean Dig Me Out was heavy, and The Hot Rock was an art-rock masterpiece, but All Hands is definitely a fun interlude between The Hot Rock and One Beat

Severian 02.19.2016 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
Man that was just such a fun record! I think of all their records this is the most straight up fun record, its not too serious even while it has some serious tracks. It feels like a "no pressure" record of tunes they just wanted to put out!

I mean Dig Me Out was heavy, and The Hot Rock was an art-rock masterpiece, but All Hands is definitely a fun interlude between The Hot Rock and One Beat


Yeah, AHOTBO surprised me at first with how loose and borderline bouncy it sounded. So little distortion! But soon I was humming those songs all over the damn place. Admittedly, it's the SK album I've listened to the least. But it has its place in their catalogue for sure.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Severian
Yeah, AHOTBO surprised me at first with how loose and borderline bouncy it sounded. So little distortion! But soon I was humming those songs all over the damn place. Admittedly, it's the SK album I've listened to the least. But it has its place in their catalogue for sure.


Revisit it please.. it is a totally FUN record and it will stick with you. I think it is most reflective of what LIVE S-K is, just a lot of fun! Indeed its what I missed SOOOOOOOOO much during the hiatus and why I was glad to have Wild Flag and Corin Tucker Band to fill in the fun shows gap!

All Hands on the Bad One was THEE record of 2001 for me. I listened to it like EVERY day and had that CD with me like EVERYWHERE I went. In fact, I think its the S-K record that I listened to the most aside from how much I worshiped at the church of Dig Me Out when it came out. The Hot Rock is still me favorite for many many personal reasons, BUT All Hands is a totally kick ass record.. I may just have to re-rank it on my list

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 04:12 PM

was just listening to All Hands again and was transported back in time to being a teenager, smoking pot in the bushes of a park on my way walking to high school... wow! its always amazing how vivid your memories are when triggered by something.. a total flashback! Its like, I can not just see myself, I can see that entire moment in every single detail.. the colors of the bushes and the grass in that dim gray overcast morning... the smells.. my own thoughts that morning!! even EXACTLY how was feeling to each specific song on my headphones...

whoa... THIS is why I love music. My memory is fucked from smoking pot for twenty years BUT its all in there somewhere, I just have a fucked up filing system. I need triggers to bring up the files of memory..

Toilet & Bowels 02.19.2016 05:37 PM

I don't have the extra tracks from The Spells, I didn't even know there were any. I only have the Age of Backwards CD. I'd appreciate it a lot if you uploaded the extra stuff please thank you.

The Soup Nazi 02.19.2016 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
I don't have the extra tracks from The Spells, I didn't even know there were any. I only have the Age of Backwards CD. I'd appreciate it a lot if you uploaded the extra stuff please thank you.


They're not Age Of Backwards extras/outtakes; they're four songs Carrie and Mary recorded circa 2000 looking to make a Spells LP. Here's the story goddammit:

http://www.npr.org/sections/monitorm...t_vs_bird.html

Toilet & Bowels 02.19.2016 05:55 PM

Although I liked a few tracks on All Hands I found it a bit disappointing after Hot Rock (my first SK record), I didn't understand why after making such and unusual and unique record as The Hot Rock they would basically regress to more simplified and normally structured songs. But I guess it's sort of comparable to SY putting out DDN and then writing songs like My Friend Goo and Mary Christ.

Severian 02.19.2016 07:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
was just listening to All Hands again and was transported back in time to being a teenager, smoking pot in the bushes of a park on my way walking to high school... wow! its always amazing how vivid your memories are when triggered by something.. a total flashback! Its like, I can not just see myself, I can see that entire moment in every single detail.. the colors of the bushes and the grass in that dim gray overcast morning... the smells.. my own thoughts that morning!! even EXACTLY how was feeling to each specific song on my headphones...

whoa... THIS is why I love music. My memory is fucked from smoking pot for twenty years BUT its all in there somewhere, I just have a fucked up filing system. I need triggers to bring up the files of memory..


Oh yeah I was all over that shit in '01. It was my favorite SK album for a while. Saw them several times during that period. I felt that One Beat's seriousness and the thunderous rock drumming on it and the Woods kinda edged AHOTBO out, but it's a great album.

Imma listen to it right now actually.

Then the Hot Rock. "The Size of our Love" gets me every Fucking time.

Severian 02.19.2016 07:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
Although I liked a few tracks on All Hands I found it a bit disappointing after Hot Rock (my first SK record), I didn't understand why after making such and unusual and unique record as The Hot Rock they would basically regress to more simplified and normally structured songs. But I guess it's sort of comparable to SY putting out DDN and then writing songs like My Friend Goo and Mary Christ.


My Friend Goo = pretty much the only Sonic Youth song that I always skip.

In fact I'd prefer to pretend it was never made. I cut it from the version of Goo on my iPod.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Soup Nazi
They're not Age Of Backwards extras/outtakes; they're four songs Carrie and Mary recorded circa 2000 looking to make a Spells LP. Here's the story goddammit:

http://www.npr.org/sections/monitorm...t_vs_bird.html

More or less same shit. I haven't read the article yet but if remember correctly from the first time when i initially downloaded them from the Monitor Mix that Carrie said they were songs that had already been recorded but needed some fixes and remastering.

Either way if anyone needs them let me know, couple years ago i sent them to like 20 people here so apparently their harder to find then i thought.

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
Although I liked a few tracks on All Hands I found it a bit disappointing after Hot Rock (my first SK record), I didn't understand why after making such and unusual and unique record as The Hot Rock they would basically regress to more simplified and normally structured songs. But I guess it's sort of comparable to SY putting out DDN and then writing songs like My Friend Goo and Mary Christ.

I can see why you would say that if Hot Rock was your introduction to SK but if you zoom out it wasn't entirely a regression so much as Hot Rock was simply an outlier. Indeed if you were yo take it out of the discography then All Hands really does feel like a progression and indeed follows that trend through One Beat, the Woods, and No Cities to Love. Perhaps because Hot Rock is so fundamentally different and unique from any other SK record and even side project releases that is why i put it as Number One

SuchFriendsAreDangerous 02.19.2016 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels
I don't have the extra tracks from The Spells, I didn't even know there were any. I only have the Age of Backwards CD. I'd appreciate it a lot if you uploaded the extra stuff please thank you.

I have very limited internet but tonight i will send them. PM and i can email them to you directly and maybe if more people are interested ill post them on youtube

The Soup Nazi 02.19.2016 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuchFriendsAreDangerous
I have very limited internet but tonight i will send them. PM and i can email them to you directly and maybe if more people are interested ill post them on youtube


Actually, all of you critters can download the four songs from the link I posted above two hours ago! Just scroll the hell back! There's a little artwork and all! Jesus Christ!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth