Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Do you have a 'tester' record? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=13937)

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:26 AM

Do you have a 'tester' record?
 
An album that, if you discovered a person didn't like it, you might have to wonder whether you could ever truly consider them a friend.

screamingskull 06.15.2007 05:29 AM

The Pixies - Doolittle

 


I don't understand how anyone could not love that record. But i do have friends who are not pixies fans.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 05:33 AM

If a person doesn't like Hip Hop or ethnic music, I immediately think that they are narrow minded. It's not always the case, though.

sonicl 06.15.2007 05:35 AM

No.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 05:38 AM

You wouldn't find many people who like Cowboy Junkies, anyway.

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:38 AM

I don't hate Doolittle, but have never been that much of a fan either. The Pixies came along at a time when I was listening to other stuff.

sonicl 06.15.2007 05:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
You wouldn't find many people who like Cowboy Junkies, anyway.

I'm flicking v-signs in the general direction of London. Can you feel them?

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:42 AM

If you really couldn't find ANYTHING to like in this, then I'd have issues. You wouldn't need to love it, as such, just enjoy it - at least a bit.

 

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
You wouldn't find many people who like Cowboy Junkies, anyway.


I dunno about that. The Trinity Sessions is a great album.

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
If a person doesn't like Hip Hop or ethnic music, I immediately think that they are narrow minded. It's not always the case, though.


In my experience, fans of Hip Hop and 'ethnic' music can be amongst the most narrow-minded people I've met.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 05:46 AM

ew!

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
ew!


It's true, especially so far as Hip Hop goes. I don't see too many enlightened minds sitting at the back of a 25 bus, that's for sure.

sun city girl 06.15.2007 05:47 AM

velvet underground - white light/white heat

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 05:48 AM

Rock fans are much worse. How many people who play or listen to world music do you know to make such a claim?

demonrail666 06.15.2007 05:53 AM

I'd generally agree about fans of World music, but see no real indication of major open-mindedness with your average (and I stress average) 50 Cent fan. And this coming from someone who likes Rap a lot.

demonrail666 06.15.2007 06:03 AM

Anyone closing themselves off from a genre in its entirety is clearly a fool, but this isn't about genres but single albums, etc.

So while I generally see nothing of any value in this:
 


I see an awful lot to love in this:

 

ALIEN ANAL 06.15.2007 06:03 AM

beastie boys in general

gmku 06.15.2007 07:37 AM

Two, actually: The Modern Lovers (s/t) and Sticky Fingers.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 07:42 AM

You must have an enormous amount of mates, then.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 07:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demonrail666
Anyone closing themselves off from a genre in its entirety is clearly a fool, but this isn't about genres but single albums, etc.

So while I generally see nothing of any value in this:


 


I see an awful lot to love in this:



 


What has 50 Cent got to do with it?

the ikara cult 06.15.2007 07:52 AM

P.I.M.P may have deplorable subject matter, but its a great tune.
Most of my freinds arent into the kind of music i like anyway, so we kinda club together around things that i find some mild level of enjoyment in.

jimbrim 06.15.2007 07:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demonrail666
In my experience, fans of Hip Hop and 'ethnic' music can be amongst the most narrow-minded people I've met.


I totally agree with this, all of my friends that like hip-hop, only listen to hip-hop. They usually question the fact that i enjoy listening to guitar music or anything that isnt hip hop for that matter.

jon boy 06.15.2007 07:56 AM

i used to think that if someone didnt like the music i liked then i wouldnt like them but this i have discovered to be very stupid. all music has its place and i dont really have an album tester to speak of.

gmku 06.15.2007 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
You must have an enormous amount of mates, then.


Too many.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 08:18 AM

One's friends are not everyone's friends, though. Just because your friends are musically narrow minded, it doesn't mean that anyone else's friends are the same way. Again, the same can be easily said of a huge chunk of people into rock music. I find a lot of posters on here terribly narrow minded, when it comes to music.

MellySingsDoom 06.15.2007 08:18 AM


 


Anyone who doesn't enjoy at least one song on this magnum opus has ears of cloth, and smells of Marmite.

jimbrim 06.15.2007 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Again, the same can be easily said of a huge chunk of people into rock music.

I agree with this also, all of my friends are divided into these seperate subcultures when it come's to music taste's, but i can always hold a decent convosation with each of them as i know a bit about each genre.

That's why i don't have a 'tester' album, beacuse my friends are all into different types of music.

Bicorn Halfelven 06.15.2007 08:40 AM

If my friends don't like Earth 2 or listening to the Merzbox all the way through, I kill them and eat them.

pbradley 06.15.2007 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MellySingsDoom


 


Anyone who doesn't enjoy at least one song on this magnum opus has ears of cloth, and smells of Marmite.

Ah! This one time I sat in on my friend's film class at Irvine Valley College while they were watching Easy Rider and this typical know-nothing neo con idiot whined about the drug trip scene. I almost told him off but, like I said, I was just sitting in.

gmku 06.15.2007 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
I find a lot of posters on here terribly narrow minded, when it comes to music.


yeah, especially the ones who are into stuff I've never heard of and know I wouldn't like.

floatingslowly 06.15.2007 11:25 AM


 


a fan of TJAMC is a friend of mine although this one works too:


 



one of my wife's friends had a Love & Rockets t-shirt on when I met him. I said "Hi, you're my new best friend".

also on the list: any dancehall reggae

dionysusundone 06.15.2007 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floatingslowly

 


a fan of TJAMC is a friend of mine although this one works too:



 



one of my wife's friends had a Love & Rockets t-shirt on when I met him. I said "Hi, you're my new best friend".

also on the list: any dancehall reggae


You just named off three of my favorite things. Awesome.
I question anybody that doesn't like The Residents at least a little bit.

sarramkrop 06.15.2007 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmku
yeah, especially the ones who are into stuff I've never heard of and know I wouldn't like.


Ohhhh!! Look who's replied to my post! Hello Andrew!! How's it going?

gmku 06.15.2007 11:45 AM

Not bad, Hank.

MellySingsDoom 06.15.2007 11:49 AM


Quote:

Originally Posted by floatingslowly
also on the list: any dancehall reggae


I know I've waffled on about this before, but I have a real problem with the batty-boy murdering lyrics of some dancehall. If someone told me that, for example, T.O.K.'s "Chi Chi Man" had great words, then they'd be on my shit-list forever.

floatingslowly 06.15.2007 12:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MellySingsDoom
I know I've waffled on about this before, but I have a real problem with the batty-boy murdering lyrics of some dancehall.


you are totally right, and I cannot respect someone who preaches "one love" in one breath and then turns right around and condones beating / killing gays the next.

however, like all genres, you have your good and your bad.

personally, I like the rasta stuff more than the music made by gangstas, but Jamaican culture does tend to swing to the extremely homophobic (this is exacerbated by lower standards of education).

either way, "rapping" (successfully) at 140 bpm takes skill.


PS: I have no idea who/what T.O.K. (or a Chi Chi Man) is. my collection is fairly old.

atsonicpark 06.15.2007 12:08 PM

no, that's silly, but i have never met a person who didn't like early misfits stuff (danzig era) so if i met someone like that i'd be... intrigued.

Rob Instigator 06.15.2007 12:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Rock fans are much worse. How many people who play or listen to world music do you know to make such a claim?


rock n roll is world music. ALL music is world music. it is made in the world.
"world music" as a genre is a bullshit catch-all for anything not made by white people. It is a dumb term.

gmku 06.15.2007 01:42 PM

I think I was being "tested" a couple weeks ago at a dinner with some of my wife's work acquaintances. They knew I had a rep as a music snob and am opening a record store, so they brought out what they thought was some edgy stuff--old albums by the Roches and an a capella group called the Nylons. I thought I'd barf. But I kept my cool and politely nodded, and murmurred little nothings like, "Hmm. Yes. I see. Really?"

demonrail666 06.15.2007 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator
rock n roll is world music. ALL music is world music. it is made in the world.
"world music" as a genre is a bullshit catch-all for anything not made by white people. It is a dumb term.


The same occurs in film, where 'World Cinema' refers to any film made outside of Western Europe and the USA. It also gives special emphasis to films that adopt certain native 'folk' traditions. It's a double-edged sword. It promotes a nation's films but imposes constraints on the types of films that are produced. Many countries churn out pseudo-folk films to satisfy a Western idea of what that nation 'is'.

Most of the big-name directors in 'World Cinema' are far more popular in the West than they are in their own countries.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth