Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Bands that should reform, or perhaps never went away. (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=17859)

Glice 11.19.2007 03:18 PM

Bands that should reform, or perhaps never went away.
 
From other threads. I'm sure we've had this before, but I'm not much of a one for caring about duplicate threads.

So, given that it's very unlikely that the likes of the Pumpkins, MBV or The Pixies have any decent reason to reform except money (a fair reason, but I'm not going to their shows because of it), who should be reforming? We've had Loop and Slowdive nominated already, I'd like to see Cluster or, ideally, Urusei Yatsura reform. Let's have some thoughts.

NB - the Pistols are exempt from criticism. Not because they're the godfathers of punk or anything, but because they're entirely justified in being utter cunts. And long may they continue to be so.

A Thousand Threads 11.19.2007 03:23 PM

Cluster broke up?
I didn't know that.

Someone from this board has seen them live, i think it was Savage Colone, and said it was the most boring concert he's ever been to.

Toxa 11.19.2007 03:23 PM

definetly geraldine fibbers.

Glice 11.19.2007 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by A Thousand Threads
Cluster broke up?
I didn't know that.

Someone from this board has seen them live, i think it was Savage Colone, and said it was the most boring concert he's ever been to.


Only discovered they used to be great recently, I assumed they'd split up at some point. I am hence covered by the part of the thread title reading '...perhaps they never went away'. Ergo I win.

A Thousand Threads 11.19.2007 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Ergo I win.

Congratulations.
Here's your cup
 






anyways
I don't know if they are still living, but i'd love to see 13th Floor Elevator.
oh yeah, and Captain Beefheart.

SYRFox 11.19.2007 04:05 PM

Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Slowdive
Fly Pan Am
Girls Against Boys

Those are the one who came in my mind first

Torn Curtain 11.19.2007 04:08 PM

I'd like to see the Smiths (even if a reunion will only happen because of the money).

drrrtyboots 11.19.2007 04:17 PM

Polvo is making one of my dreams come true even though its only for one show apparently and Unwound obviously.

Savage Clone 11.19.2007 04:18 PM

I saw Cluster once.
I fell asleep. Seriously.

SYRFox 11.19.2007 04:22 PM

Ha, and, Out Hud!

val-holla-ing 11.19.2007 05:41 PM

faith no more
sleater-kinney
os mutantes (the right way)
bone thuggs-n-harmony
super_collider
cibo matto

Everyneurotic 11.19.2007 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
...
Girls Against Boys

...


they reunited this summer or before, but they were performing ED: can't remember which album but they did a don't look back this summer.

ondskan 11.19.2007 06:48 PM

I'm not shure if I really want to see Kyuss reunite, but it would be so so so exciting to see what they would come up with.

Danny Himself 11.19.2007 07:38 PM

Bring back the Zombie Beach Boys.

batreleaser 11.19.2007 07:43 PM

Drive like Jehu, Crass, Big Black (yeah right), Integrity (hardcore needs a kick to the ass), DNA (another never will happen), John Cale and Lou Reed should get in the studio and make an experimental alblum, i cant think right now, a lotta punk bands could get back, but id fear it would never be the same. a part of me thinks bands that have broken up should stay broken up except for maybe a victory tour or something, but they shudnt start recoridng again, i mean if ure a great influential band why fuckin bother potentially fuckin up a close to perfect catalog. the only bands that have comeback and made excellent to good music are wire and mission of burma, the new dino jr aint bad either, but it certainly does not hold up to bug, YLAOM, or self titles, and the stooges alblum, cmon now. reunion tours=cool especially for the fans who were there from the beginning and the fans who were too young to see them live back in the day, reunion alblums=a very risky gamble that many of my favorite bands have totally shit all over.

Toilet & Bowels 11.19.2007 07:48 PM

big black did a reunion show last year

Toilet & Bowels 11.19.2007 07:49 PM

cluster played a show in london earlier this year, i very nearly almost went, but then my friend i was going with pulled out at the last minute and i while i was curious to see what they're up to nowadays (having only heard their 70s stuff) i thought theirs is the type of music that probably isn't that interesting live anyway, being electronic.

Toilet & Bowels 11.19.2007 07:49 PM

i'd like to see fushitsusha get back on it, find a new drummer or whatever it is that is preventing them from being an ongoing concern. also high rise, harry pussy, the shadow ring and the jesus lizard i'd like to see reform, just to see them live. there are plenty of bands i wished i'd seen but if they reformed they probably wouldn't be anything like i'd want them to be anyway.

also, not so much a reformation, but i'd like to see mark e smith get some musicians with a bit of imagination to join the fall. i think he's screwing himself by having this thing about not playing with people who like the fall, because that just leaves him to play with oasis fans and the like.

the ikara cult 11.19.2007 07:55 PM

ikara colt!
Mclusky

ZEROpumpkins 11.20.2007 04:32 AM

Fugazi, Pavement, Guided by Voices and Unwound (so they can re-issue some albums)

sonicl 11.20.2007 04:40 AM

Sisters of Mercy, please. I'd probably wee myself with excitement if they did a Don't Look Back of "First and Last and Always".

sarramkrop 11.20.2007 04:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sonicl
Sisters of Mercy, please. I'd probably wee myself with excitement if they did a Don't Look Back of "First and Last and Always".


Weren't they touring only a couple of years ago or more recently? I'm dead sure that they were on the bill of one of those summer festivals that are generally played by bands like The Mission etc. The sort of festival nobody in the right mind likes going to.

_slavo_ 11.20.2007 04:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SYRFox
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Slowdive
Fly Pan Am
Girls Against Boys



All four great bands !

Bertrand 11.20.2007 04:49 AM

The Nerves

sonicl 11.20.2007 04:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
Weren't they touring only a couple of years ago or more recently? I'm dead sure that they were on the bill of one of those summer festivals that are generally played by bands like The Mission etc. The sort of festival nobody in the right mind likes going to.

Yes, but the Sisters of Mercy that plays from time to time these days never strikes me as a "proper" Sisters of Mercy, it's Andrew Eldritch and a few hired hands.

sonicl 11.20.2007 04:56 AM

Oh, yeah, I'd also like to see Bitch Magnet play, if anyone could arrange it.

atsonicpark 11.20.2007 05:05 AM

I think bands usually break up for the right reasons, and therefore I don't see much point in reunions or whatever usually... only one band i can think of, though, that I'd LOVE to see get back together: captain beefheart. not "The magic band" (since they released an album and played some shows a few years ago), but captain beefheart himself WITH the magic band. The fact that they broke up immediately following their best album (and there's no bootlegs that I know of with "ice cream for crow" songs on it)... yeah.

sonicl 11.20.2007 05:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nefeli
just occured to me- is Glice asking about reforming and performing? or about reforming and making new records?

The two bands that I've mentioned, I would be even more delighted with a reformation if I got to hear new recorded material from them as well to see them play.

sarramkrop 11.20.2007 05:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nefeli
just occured to me- is Glice asking about reforming and performing? or about reforming and making new records?
if its the first, i would like to have a chance seeing dead can dance live, because its one of shows i regret missing during the 90ties.


I have seen them a couple of years ago. I was never too keen on them, but I came to appreciate them more.

One note about Dead Can Dance: they are a pair of fascists. We went to the after show party and they barred everyone from smoking in the building.

I didn't know that Silver Apples were still about, according to that racist turd. I'd like to see them live. Abba could be good if they reformed for a while. I can't really get all that excited about reunions, even if I try. One of the worst that I went to was The Velvet Underground. They were truly terrible. Death In June, on the other hand, were quite good when I've seen them live.

sonicl 11.20.2007 05:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarramkrop
I didn't know that Silver Apples were still about, according to that racist turd. I'd like to see them live.

One of them died a few years ago, but Simeon is still alive and well and doing that thing he does. By co-incidence I was reading a review of one of their (his) shows only yesterday. It was in the current issue of Plan B, I think.

_slavo_ 11.20.2007 05:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nefeli
sisters of mercy were touring indeed. the show here was awful, but cant be sure how much of this was band's fault - i didnt go, even if i used to love them.


I've seen them supporting Depeche Mode - a truly awful experience indeed.

sonicl 11.20.2007 05:22 AM

Well, yeah, I saw them about ten years ago and it was pretty poor. That's why I want a "proper" SoM.

Maybe what I want is a time machine set to take me back to 1984.

Glice 11.20.2007 01:08 PM

I faintly know the Sisters Of Mercy's current tour guitarist.

Nefeli - I don't know what I'm talking about. Whatever you want to impute is fine by me.

I'm tempted to list a load of bands from my teenhood, but they may disappoint the adult me. Although I'm sure that wouldn't apply to Prolapse.

Inhuman 11.20.2007 01:20 PM

Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Cibo Matto are excellent choices. Keep in mind that Yuka Honda and Miho Hatori both do solo projects, and they're great. If you haven't, check out "Smokey & Miho". It's Miho and a guitarist doing covers of Brazilian Folk songs

Also:
REFUSED (....are fucking dead)
RAEIN
HOT CROSS
Q AND NOT U

SYRFox 11.20.2007 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Everyneurotic
they reunited this summer or before, but they were performing ED: can't remember which album but they did a don't look back this summer.


Yeah you're right (the album was Venus Luxure No1 Baby), but I meant, new album =( anyway in an interview in the french magazine Noise, one of the member (can't remember who) said they weren't planning any new album at all...

atsonicpark 11.20.2007 09:14 PM

godheadsilo reforming would be okay, but enemy mine were better ...

Everyneurotic 11.21.2007 12:26 AM

the cows should have never broken up.

syrfox: that's the album i posted but then doubted about myself for a bit and just plain said i didn't remember which one.

never saw the big fuss about godheadsilo, they were ok but nothing special.

atsonicpark 11.21.2007 12:50 AM

there lies the crux of the biscuit!

Cantankerous 11.21.2007 12:55 AM

nirvana.
ha.

Sonic Youth 37 11.21.2007 01:05 AM

Hum
The (Original) Misfits (that means with Danzig)
Death From Above 1979


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth