Whats Up With Jewish People Ignoring The Rest of the Holocaust?
 

It is that time of year again, where the Holocaust is all over the TV and the schools. But it has always made me so upset, to here numbers of six million jews left and right, but never hear mention of the other 5 million "subhumans" who died along side the European Jews in Hitler's empire. Only one teacher out of the dozens in my life has ever brought this fact up. Why does everybody want to forget the non-Jewish deaths but not the Jewish? It doesn't make anysense how the Nazis could have systematically murdered almost 12 million people, and only 6 million are ever made mention of.

Why?

Cos you touch yourself at night.

Well, it's a matter of common knowledge here, that also many gypsies, social democrats, catholics, gays and communists died in the concentration camps, but i don't know how this is communicated to the rest of the world.

HBO did a special on the Homosexuals who were persecuted not too long ago, and it was a really eye opening, the nazis didn't kill most lesbians cause it was thought they could brainwash them into being straight, whereas gay men were outright despised, infact in the early years of the Nazi party, one of Hitler's top men Ernst Rohm, leader of the SA "aka brownshirts" was gay, and ended up dead soon after they took power

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History..._the_Holocaust

Yeah, in american schools they never bring this up. What is the deal?

the american school system is one of the greatest breeders of ignorance in this planet. god the average education level of american high school graduates is apalling. they teach you driving? wtf...

if i ever have kids, they'll be homeschooled (im not a fucking christian-- i'll just lock them in my private library all day :D )

its not just the high schools. the colleges and universities miss this issue everytime as well. the intellectual community fails to address it, there isn't much literature at all, and it seems to me that one day the memories of those other 5 million subhuman non-Jewish Eastern Europeans (mostly Polish/Slavic/Ethnic Russian) will be put to rest and the world will forget. that will be a terrible terrible day. These people were called "gypsies" and their numbers are staggering. While there were only a few hundred thousand ethnic "gypsies" in Poland and Czechelslovakia, there were millions of average citizens and millions of Jews, and all died together in Mass murder.

Is all I will say for the moment. Please stop this line of thought because it's very, very dangerous, which I shall explain if and when I can be bothered.

I remember it coming up every year we learned about it, but no, nobody seems to pay attention to it.

I think the main reason Jews are focused on is because 6 million is A LOT of Jews. There are 18 million Jews in the world today. Of course Jewish people are going to focus on it more, because it was there relatives. People always are more upset about things that hit closer to home unfortunately.

^^^ oh, tempting.

nothing like causing strife over the internet....

what can i do to bring the danger to its conclusion? :D

The Jewish people are the only ones with the numbers to be able to keep that part of it alive, that memory. the thing was that the Nazis did get rid of over 5 million gays, gypsies, undesirables, retarted people, mentally "deficient" people, but they also happened to blame much of their ills on the hebrew people, and they made it a point from the beginning to demonize the hebrews as the biggest single threat to their nazi german state. it was a convenient scapegoat, especially since many of the jews were welathy or well off people, and their asssets could be plundered by the nazi regime to further fund their sick nationalist socialist agenda. the other people were people under the rardar of europe at the time and the modern world at this time. homeless, homosexuals, drifetrs, mental "deficients" etc.

Stalin did the same thing in Russia, killing over 16 million of his own people. fucking shit russians.

you should not start threads about things you don't understand.

I concur with both Rob Instigator and Everyneurotic. I would also like to add that saying 'what's up with Jewish people ignoring the rest of the holocaust' begs the response 'they were busy being murdered, fuckwit'.

check it, a) i know more then I let on.

b) i meant jewish people today.

the issue remains. how could there be a mass genocide and half of the story not be told? What if they neglected to mention half of the jewish lives lost? would the museum of tolerance tolerate people only acknowledging 3 million jewish deaths instead of six? that has been my whole point.

you can't make ammends if you only look at half of the situation. until everyone realizes that this happens EVERYDAY, and that is happened directly to millions more then mentioned publically (IT IS A CRIME BY THE WAY, TO DENY TO THE HOLOCAUST, so what about denying or ignoring the others, is that not also a crime?), then it will not ever stop. there will continue to be genocide/politicide across the world. it isn't stopping in sudan on a mass scale, in fact it is escalating. in every nation on the earth, in small pockets of isolation it occurs on a small scale affecting only a few hundred, but a few hundred lives taken for no reason what so ever. that is my point. we must remember EVERYTHING in detail, so as not to become as apathetic as our grandparents were an are still today. genocide anywhere is genocide everywhere

My point is more to do with the phrasing of the question 'what's up with Jewish people ignoring 'the rest' of the holocaust'. I'm sorry, call me a bigot and a racist all you like, but if it were my people that were murdered/ being murdered (I'm an English Catholic) I would be ever so slightly more concerned about my own people (especially if there were an overwhelming majority of them) being killed, or having been killed, than I would about a culture to which I am slightly less attached.

To re-iterate, just on the off chance your comprehension skills aren't so hot - I am, at present, criticising THE WORDING of the question 'what is up with JEWISH PEOPLE ignoring THE REST of the holocaust', which is idiotic beyond belief. You are more than welcome to recind on that.

Perhaps I'll be arsed to deal with the rest of your half-baked reactionary bullshit later, but lets leave that one point to settle for a second.

I'm tempted to say "the holocaust never happened" and watch the fireworks. But I'll resist.

I think the question is a decent one, but it's not "Jewish people" who ignore it, it's everyone. I'm Jewish by blood, but I wasn't there and I didn't lose anyone in it - I'm no more relevant to the holocaust than anyone else and I don't feel any more qualified to talk about it than anyone else. I know a Jewish survivor - she mentions the gypsies quite often. Jews themselves today really have little to do with the holocaust, much like Germans today have nothing to do with the Nazis - aside from perhaps the Israeli nationalists, which is a whole 'nother issue.

Similar to what AssBlaster said, just because I'm of Jewish decent doesn't mean I'm more concerned with "my people" surviving than I am with the gypsies. It is an altogether different question if you're referring to only the ones who experienced it first hand, but I believe that would be addressing a very small number of people...

Top 5 reasons George Bush isn't doing shit about Africa:

5. He can't pronounce Africa
4. Africans haven't tried to make any terrorist attacks on the US since Emmet Brown and Marty McFly outsmarted those Libyans.
3. He bet money on the US basketball team for the next summer olympics
2. He can't think of any good lies to make to justify doing something about Africa, only honest truths
1. No oil in Africa

there is a lot of oil in africa.

the newish memorial in berlin is to the 'murdered jews of europe' caused some controvesy because people began saying 'well what about all the jews that were not from europe'?

having actually been to concentration camps i can say that they dont just talk about the jews but all of the people who were killed there.

I'm not too sure whether you're being discengenuous for the purposes of irony... but whatever... being of German decent is a different context, when talking about the holocaust, to talking from the point of view of someone who witnessed, or has in their cultural history, 67% of their race destroyed (ok, exaggeration, 67% of European Jewry). Everyone has blood on their hands to some extent (cf Hannah Arendt's 'Eichmann and the Holocaust). But I dislike this attempt to put the emphasis on the Jews to redress the balance of the holocaust. It is far and away from their concern to stand up and say, "Actually, it wasn't just us, there were these other guys killed too", although in modern Germany it is the Jews who are doing the most to emphasise the other people who were killed, and the Isreali people are likewise, in recent years, doing likewise.

Hmm. I'll write more later, I'm tired and need an orange juice.

haven't you been paying attention? the jewish people were not an overwhelming majority, it is just publicised that way. 5 million to 6 million?

1/2 vs 5/12?

majority?

half baked?
come on man, even a seven year old could understand the problem here. genocide is not something to joke about. it is not a my people your people kind of thing. it is of global significance, because a threat to humanity anywhere is a threat to humanity everywhere. the only reason there is a continuation of the genocide in sudan is because there IS oil in Africa. the fact that genocide continues is a testimony to the apathy of the human race, and the whole point of remembering the holocaust is to end apathy and end genocide, but if you remember the holocaust in an apathetic way (i.e. only looking at half the story, and neglecting the rest, remaining apathetic to those who died that were NOT jewish, the five million!) you preserve apathy itself.

Let me revise: Nigeria is the only African country in OPEC. US/EU industry already has its grubby paws into African oil in the other countries.

Nigeria is estimated to hold upwards of 20% of the global reserves. Sudan, Congo Brazzaville, Cameroon, Chad, Gabon and South Africa all produce marketable and even exportable quantities of oil. there is indeed oil in africa, as well as every other natural resource our modern world is dependent on.

Ok, I'm giving up on this argument at the end of this post, unless anyone particularly wants me to clarify any difficult points.

First: The title of this thread is "What's up with JEWISH people ignoring the rest of the holocaust?" I emphasise Jewish for a good reason: this title gives the impression that the impetus for emphasising the other people killed in the holocaust lies with the Jews. It doesn't. If it does, it lies as much with them as with anyone else.

Second: I believe the statistics of races and people killed in the holocaust runs something along the lines of: 5 million Jews; 1 million gypsies; hundreds of thousands of 'others', including Christians, so-called communists/ resistance, disabled people and gays. There were more Jews killed. I am saying this, and this is probably a good point to read carefully, not to try and emphasise that the Jewish people 'deserve' the pity of the rest of the world, but to emphasise that there is a good reason for that emphasis.

Third: Only an idiot would try and claim that the genocide in the second world war was anything other than abhorrent - it is a global concern, and a lesson that everyone, no matter where they come from, should learn from, and as you point out, something that hasn't been learnt from - you mention Sudan, I could just as easily mention the activities in former Yugoslavia or where ever. On this we agree.

Fourth: My main point is that your thread starts with the statement: "What's up with JEWISH people ignoring the rest of the holocaust?". If you say it is a global concern to learn from the holocaust, and remember all those that were killed, not just Jews, then why would you emphasise Jews in your title, rather than saying, "I would like to take this opportunity to remember those killed in the holocaust" which is infinitely less provocative. To be honest, I was inclined to infer certain prejudices which run alongside political rastafarianism - I have not, and will not, raise those, but you need to be extra super duper careful about how you say things when talking about such an emotive subject. This is not a statement with any religious, cultural or ethnic sway - everyone needs to be careful what they say.


Just as an addendum to all of this: criticisms of 'other' people's apathy rarely serve to engender anything other than the self-perpetuation of your criticism; ie, the statement is perfectly Hegelian. There is no other in this situation, there is only mourning.

I don't agree with that at all.

The US should be more concerned with Venezuela as led by Chavez. Venezuela is ascending within OPEC and will eventually become effective leader, most likely.

not enough....or we would be there...

The USA should be (and indeed are) more concerned with the ever growing Chinese economy that is taking the world by storm methinks

Yes, of course. I meant "more concerned" only in relation to oil and OPEC in particular.

Are you saying don't ask questions? about subjects you dont understand?

?Also - how can it be proven that -Jews- ignore the rest of the holocaust and the war?

no, i was directing my post to the originator of this thread, who is a raging idiot.

and so i take this thread seriously for a second, i will say that the holocaust has been simplified and stripped down to the barest of of words, descriptions and interpretations which are: nazis are bad, millions of jews were killed, it's some of the worst things to ever happen to humanity. all of these are true, without argument, but there's more to it than that. yes, more minorities should also be remembered, but also, it seems that the descendents of gypsies, catholics, gays, comunists, etc. would rather forget about them getting persecuted and going halfway thru extermination, unlike the jewish people, who always make a point about remembering the past so it won't happen again. i also can say, that most rememberance of the holocaust are from jewish people to jewish people, not directed at the world, even though it gets massive amounts of coverage worldwide.

because jews are jews.

as raging an idiot you think i am, you still don't get it. Germany allowed the slaughter of almost twelve million people in extermination camps and by roaming death sqauds, half were jews, and as we rasta say, half that story has never been told. They ignored the situation to the point of apathy. to ignore it in anyway today, would be the first steps towards returning to that German sentiment. genocide is the worst autrocity in human history, and the 21st century should be the time when it is finally put to an end, but this takes empathy and action from ALL people, not just those afflicted directly.

An excellent satire on the holocaust and how people tend to treat it. A must see:

The Pity Card

this thread is pretty pointless..
if you're interested in finding out more about the holocaust, the best way would be picking up a book..
once you do that, you will see the list of all the victims.. the numbers do vary from source to source, but the general idea of what happened is there..
i don't think the jewish population is trying to cover up the fact others were persecuted, they were the largest group to suffer..

like i said, picking up a book would be the best answer...

I believe it also caused controversy when people found out that the company that supplied the anti-graffiti stuff that coats the monument manufactured Zyklon B for the Nazis.

"Zyklooooooonn, Zyklooooooooon Beeeeeeeeee Zombieeeeeeeee...."

Super creepy.

Did you see the in depth pictures of 'his' surgery on 'his' website? That was largely unecessary.

Not sure I saw those...

But this:


And this:


is enough. ew.