The best pie
 

???

Key lime pie (sp?).



Yum.

that's not a pie, it's a tart.

You sure?
I've only heard it called key lime pie.

pies have a layer of pastry on top. you americans need to update your language with the times. i've even heard americans refer to pizza as being a pie! Malarkey!

Hah, well excuse my American ignorance.
Ignore my first vote and let my new one be pumpkin pie.

Pie: dish baked in pastry-lined pan with a pastry top.

 

why didn't you mention Lemon Mirangue pie?

My dad makes really kickass ones.

Since we're talking about sweet pies which are nice enough in themselves, I'll say apple and blckcurrant. But savoury pies are preferable.

those linda mcartneys ones are actually very nice.

Layer of pastry on top?

that eliminates all of my favorites

key lime pie
lemon marange (however the fuck you spell it)
banana cream pie
french apple pie

french apple "pie" is a tart, the french themselves call it a "tarte" which is french for tart.
lemon meringue pie has a layer of meringue instead of pastry so is still a pie.

has anyone ever eaten apple pie with cheese on it?

So pumpkin pie is really a tart?
I voted apple, nothing beats a good apple pie with lots of cinnamon.

no cinnamon, its wrong. cinnamon is the single worst thing in the history of the world. i feel strongly about this sorry.

Mr Kipling makes exceedingly good apple pies.

My mum used to as well, God rest her soul.

:eek: I have nothing to say to you.

ok ok i begrudge cinnamon to other people, but none for me its like licking the floor of a taxi. ha ha

cinnamon is the best thing ever!!!!

i voted blueberry, i don't give a fuck what it's called, i love that shit!

don't listen to toliet, he's a cake man

my favorite is a peach and banana cream pie, if dropped, and none of it leaves the box it becomes a beach panana pie

Oh you're so right. No cinnamon, no apple pie. I love it sprinkled on my cappucino as well (cinnamon, not apple pie).

Cinnamon mixed into clotted cream is quite pleasant.

And a stick of cinnamon placed into hot apple juice is an excellent winter drink. Although not as excellent as a glass of port.

Oh, how I'm mocked for drinking port in the winter.

It's so appropriate. It makes you feel instantly warm and hearty. Sotherts Old Books, in Chester, has free port for the regular customers in the approach to Christmas, which is a lovely touch. Nice port, too.

Ewww, I dunno why but I find hot apple juice really really gross.

pie aye aye

hot apple juice is basically urine

my favourite pie is probably blackberry & apple

i don't really like pie, i like cake. but if i have to choose, apple pie.

i could eat a big ol' pie.:cool:

cherry, that is.

Bumped so pie discussers can piss of out of the cake thread.

Steak and Kidney

Cheesecake and pecan.

Sometimes,.side by side. Or on top of one another.

My cackle echoes.

pecan and pumpkin are great. as for fruit pies i really like raspberry, which is not on the poll. but blueberry or cherry or basically any other pie is also great.

All day breakfast pie

semantic douchebaggery aside, key lime, pumpkin, coconut cream, and a not-too-syrupy pecan pie (pecan is easy to ruin by oversweetness) all rule.

i've never had meat pies beyond chicken pot pie, but i favor the concept. meat is awesome.

also, hachis parmentier >>> shepherd's pie, if we're going to include potato-based "pies".

Yum

blackberry pie and lemon meringue

You mean meringue, which lacks a pastry crust on top is....a PIE?

PREPOSTEROUS!!

HAIR.