Check out this article...
 

It calls Rather Ripped one of the best albums of 2006, says that Daydream Nation was one of the most overrated and overlong albums of the 1980's, and says that Goo and Dirty are phenomenal noise rock albums, contrary to the opinions of "purist" indie snobs such as many people on this forum. The author was also never crazy about Jim O'Rourke being in the group. Sounds like a great person!

http://floodwatchmusic.com/blog2/200...ern-star-land/

Me,i'm rocking to Alcohol Funnycar at the moment.

Well then! Rock on.

goo isn't phenomenal. dirty is fucking awesome, though.

Becuz was seven minutes? Was this version ever released?

"karen revisited" was not a continuation of their karen carpenter
fascination. that is just lazy journalism. although not as sloth-like as the
murray street review that appeared in Q mag wherein the writer not only
said it was a sequel to "tunic" but also claimed that kim sang it. 'cause kim
and lee's voices are that interchangable, i suppose.

i guess it is if you add track 1 + track 9 together...

Oh, yeah. I forgot about that track.

erm, so what daycare? he just has an opinion like the rest of us but he is a bit lazy when it comes to knowlegdeable facts tho.....

i disagree with daydream saying its overrated and overlong but he still said it was a classic album, whats his point?

he didnt like nyc g&f, well thats not suprising as most quick fix sy fans dont...

and he didnt like jim, ok, well whatever, why did he still like the records then, again whats his point???

whats your point daycare????? why are you always trying to downgrade folk here as snobs and musos? we all have opinions so i can live with yours, you should live with others, its a bit hypocritical of you with all these posts......

anyway, thats my point! and THIS ISNT PERSONAL, ITS AMN INTERNET FORUM!!!!!!

and says that Goo and Dirty are phenomenal noise rock albums, contrary to the opinions of "purist" indie snobs such as many people on this forum.

DAYCARE ^^^^ thats bullshit^^^^^^^^^^^

I like goo more then dirty.

I'm gobsmacked that someone would even consider NYCG&F any less than an excellent SY album but then..............

eh, i can see why. there's some awesome songs, just something always seems off about it to me.

you wrote that article, didn't you daycare?!