[SuchFriendsAreDangerous]

 

Don't ask me why

[Ghostchase]

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

I've never watched Mad Men, and I probably never will but can someone sum up in a nutshell what makes a TV series about bunch of people working in something as tacky as advertising worthy of such a devoted audience?

John Hamm. One of the sexiest humans to walk the earth.

Christina Hendricks. The Greeks and other ancient civilizations craved in stone because of women like her.

And

Acting. Unknown (relatively) actors that are even more talented than that of highest calibre HBO show, or superstar Hollywood red carpet. These men and women craft a story that is heartfelt and addicting.

If you're some plot junkie looking of robots/explosions, or some cheesy Marvel story, look elsewhere.

[gmku]

I know, because why ever consider anything, a book, a movie, a work of art, music, a television show, worth your while if its subject is something you'd find disagreeable?

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

I've never watched Mad Men, and I probably never will but can someone sum up in a nutshell what makes a TV series about bunch of people working in something as tacky as advertising worthy of such a devoted audience?

[SuchFriendsAreDangerous]

While i agree with your point in general gmku i also have not watched a single episode of Mad Men because of its topic. Same reason i never watched Breaking Bad..

I love to read "different" novels, id possibly even read a novel about tv marketing or meth dealong but i had and have zero desire to watch it.

Now i must be off to watch Girl Meets World

(Sighs, NBA playoffs aren't back till tomorrow)

[gmku]

I have no problem with that. BUt T&B mplied that something was wrong with a whole audience for watching a show that he personally did not like. A whole other thing than simply expressing a personal dislike.

[guest]

 

[guest]

/// survivor finale this week

[Rob Instigator]

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

I've never watched Mad Men, and I probably never will but can someone sum up in a nutshell what makes a TV series about bunch of people working in something as tacky as advertising worthy of such a devoted audience?

when you descrfibe ANY TV show in one sentence it sounds like shit

it is a show about life, like any other good one.

[Rob Instigator]

survivor finale wednesday as well as David Letterman finale. will be a CBS marathon at casa instigator

watched Game of Thrones latest. lots of people talkl about how horrible Sansa's wedding night rape was but they fail to consider that many, if not most, women who were married off in the last 1000 years or more were raped this way on their wedding night. fucking horrible. I am glad we live when we live.

[Bytor Peltor]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

survivor finale wednesday as well as David Letterman finale. will be a CBS marathon at casa instigator

Bob Dylan is playing Letterman tonight!

For those who missed it last night, Eddie Vedder along with Paul Shaffer and the CBS Orchestra knocked, "Better Man" out of the park!

Now that most TV shows are coming to their Season's end......what good shows are starting this summer?

[Toilet & Bowels]

Originally Posted by gmku

T&B mplied that something was wrong with a whole audience for watching a show that he personally did not like.

That's not what I meant to do. I was saying that what I hear about the show's concept (a bunch of 60s alpha male advertising executives smoking cigarettes and cheating on their wives) sounds pretty unappealing to me, however Mad Men gets a lot of respect. So, I was wondering if someone could say something brief and insightful about it that might help me understand why so many people like it and that might make it appealing. Something beyond the inane drivel the person said about the great acting, hot actors and it's not about superheros. Seriously what successful drama of the last 20 years doesn't have very attractive people who are very good at acting?

[Toilet & Bowels]

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

it is a show about life, like any other good one.

what sets it apart?

[Toilet & Bowels]

Originally Posted by gmku

I know, because why ever consider anything, a book, a movie, a work of art, music, a television show, worth your while if its subject is something you'd find disagreeable?

There isn't time to watch/read/listen/visit/etc everything that is considered great, you've got to have some kind of filter.

[Rob Instigator]

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

what sets it apart?

I am not a HUGE fan, but I have enjoyed about 70% of it as I watched with my wife.

I think what sets it apart is that it explores the workplace in both nostalgic and critical ways. I think people like shows that trans;port them to a shared past, even if it is a very exclusive, boys-club, segregated, and inherently racist and sexist past.

I would not rank it on the top ten TV dramas of all time though. Like all advertising, it is a cloud of lies and misdirection disguised as solid truth, or a solid truth disguised by a cloud of lies and misdirection.

[Rob Instigator]

Originally Posted by Toilet & Bowels

There isn't time to watch/read/listen/visit/etc everything that is considered great, you've got to have some kind of filter.

that is TRUE. some things may be "great" but my mind does not give a fuck to find out, because I am deeply involved with other "great" things. Life is too too short to try and absorb everything.

[Rob Instigator]

My personal Top Ten Drama TV shows, in no particular order, and completely subjective. I do not watch too many TV dramas. I lose patience with them.

Breaking Bad
Deep Space Nine
NYPD Blue (first two seasons. HOT DAMN)
Daredevil (on the Netflix. Vincent Dinofrio is AMAZING as Wilson "The Kingpin" Fisk)
Sopranos
CSI (first two seasons were TIGHT)
Game of Thrones
Buffy The Vampire Slayer (I got into this through my first wife, and it kept getting more engrossing! damnit!)
Trek: The Next Generation
House of Cards



I never got to watch Hill Street Blues. it was a fave of my parents. My TV wtaching is ussually relegated to science/nature shows, comedies, sports, and Zimmern and Bourdain....

[LifeDistortion]

I believe one of the big appeals of Mad Men is when they make references to either pop culture from the past or big news events of the past as if they happened just that week. When a character talks about seeing the new episode of "Ed Sullivan" or we hear a comment about a news story on JFK there's a little bit of using "Mad Men" as a time-travelling device, where for us these things are decades old, but they are talking about it as if it's current and new. I do think there is an appeal to that for people, whether they are romanticizing the past as we tend to do, or simply appreciating it.

[SuchFriendsAreDangerous]

Rob, nypd blue actually is pretty good, been watching reruns of it too.. i prefer NY Undercover though, the hip hop alternative..

[Toilet & Bowels]

My top 12 (in no order) TV dramas

(drama = anything that is fictional but not comedy)

Homicide: Life on the Street
Twin Peaks
The Wire
Six Feet Under
The Sopranos
Buffy
Game of Thrones
This Is England
Generation Kill
The X Files

[Ghostchase]

Twin Peaks and The X-Files reboots are on their way... I wonder how it will all pan out?