Go Back   Sonic Youth Gossip > Sonic Gossip
Reload this Page Why do we rank a band's albums from best to worst?
Register FAQ Members List Mark Forums Read

 
Thread Tools
Old 05.09.2009, 12:12 PM   #1
summer
stalker
 
summer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 540
summer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard sucka
This can really be applied to any band, but Sonic Youth is as likely a culprit as any. Does it bug anyone else that people seem to want to rank albums on a number system, declaring one is superior/inferior over the rest? While watching "Antenna" from Jools Holland on Youtube, I noticed a comment that said "How is the new one? Is it the best of the 2000's?"

I think a question like that is pretty silly. If you were to rank a band's albums based from best to worst, it is only doing a disservice to the band, especially a band with a larger discography. You should judge an album based of its own accord and of its own merits. Say on some person's "list", Confusion is Sex were to rank, say, a #10. This isn't very fair to the album, because even if said person were to not prefer it to later Sonic Youth, this shouldn't discredit it as a lesser work. I think more people should see albums from an album-to-album basis. Comparing them to the rest is really only a detriment to the enjoyment of the music, I think.
__________________

 
summer is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:18 PM   #2
jennthebenn
expwy. to yr skull
 
jennthebenn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Maryland
Posts: 2,261
jennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's asses
Because some people enjoy doing it, it helps put the output in their own
perspective and can stir up debate and dialogue.
__________________
http://jennthebenn.tumblr.com/
jennthebenn is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:32 PM   #3
SYRFox
invito al cielo
 
SYRFox's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Paris
Posts: 7,492
SYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's asses
It's all part of the infinite delusional spiral matrix, man
SYRFox is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:33 PM   #4
jennthebenn
expwy. to yr skull
 
jennthebenn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Maryland
Posts: 2,261
jennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's assesjennthebenn kicks all y'all's asses
That too.
__________________
http://jennthebenn.tumblr.com/
jennthebenn is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:35 PM   #5
SYRFox
invito al cielo
 
SYRFox's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Paris
Posts: 7,492
SYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's asses
Not only that too, only that
SYRFox is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:50 PM   #6
Derek
invito al cielo
 
Derek's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 8,095
Derek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's assesDerek kicks all y'all's asses
Because it's fun, that's why!
Derek is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 12:55 PM   #7
SYRFox
invito al cielo
 
SYRFox's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Paris
Posts: 7,492
SYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's asses
Yep the infinite delusional spiral matrix is pure fun
SYRFox is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 01:30 PM   #8
barnaclelapse
the destroyed room
 
barnaclelapse's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Waverly, Virginia
Posts: 577
barnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's assesbarnaclelapse kicks all y'all's asses
I've never liked rankings, and I've never been very fond of ranking things myself.

Whenever I do, I always tend to go for a "In no particular order" kind of thing. I can still come up with a top-five, top-ten and so on, but I don't feel like sitting there and debating why Album A should be number one an Album C should be number two.
barnaclelapse is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 02:59 PM   #9
joe11121
expwy. to yr skull
 
joe11121's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Brantford, Canada
Posts: 1,843
joe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's assesjoe11121 kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by Derek
Because it's fun, that's why!

Yeah. I love ranking things.
joe11121 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 03:43 PM   #10
negative8ball
bad moon rising
 
negative8ball's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 122
negative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's assesnegative8ball kicks all y'all's asses
I think most people rank thinks even when they don't vocalize it (I reach for Washing Machine more often than NYC Ghosts - therefore, I Washing Machine is better etc etc) - but the Internet just provides one of those places we can all get into passionate debates ABOUT our internalized rankings...

Oh - and it's kinda fun LOL
negative8ball is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 03:54 PM   #11
demonrail666
invito al cielo
 
demonrail666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 18,510
demonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's asses
I've already ranked this thread as my 74th favourite of the year.
demonrail666 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 04:36 PM   #12
Magic Wheel Memory
the end of the ugly
 
Magic Wheel Memory's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Nowhere, NJ
Posts: 836
Magic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by summer
Say on some person's "list", Confusion is Sex were to rank, say, a #10. This isn't very fair to the album, because even if said person were to not prefer it to later Sonic Youth, this shouldn't discredit it as a lesser work.

The only thing that would mean, is that in one person's opinion, CIS ranks lower (based on one or more criteria) than 9 other SY albums. For all we know, it may be the person's 10th favorite record by any artist ever, which would be pretty remarkable.

Furthermore, if you don't believe in ranking, that means if you could only hear one SY album again, for the rest of your life, you would choose one album randomly. Is that what you would do?
__________________
www.myspace.com/infinityad
Magic Wheel Memory is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 04:41 PM   #13
dionysusundone
the end of the ugly
 
dionysusundone's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 871
dionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard suckadionysusundone cold hard sucka
I give this thread a 4.6 (outta ten)
__________________
-James
dionysusundone is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 04:43 PM   #14
summer
stalker
 
summer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 540
summer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard suckasummer cold hard sucka
...but there never will be a situation in which I will have only one album from one particular band, so why would I want to think about such things? Sure, I know I'd pick A Thousand Leaves, but still. It's kind of strange, to me.
__________________

 
summer is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 04:52 PM   #15
Magic Wheel Memory
the end of the ugly
 
Magic Wheel Memory's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Nowhere, NJ
Posts: 836
Magic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's assesMagic Wheel Memory kicks all y'all's asses
[quote=summer Sure, I know I'd pick A Thousand Leaves, but still. [/quote]

That means A Thousand Leaves, in your opinion, ranks ahead of SY's other albums on at least one criterion. You may not think it's inherently "better," but in some way or another, you prefer it. Your ranking criteria may different than someone else's.

I think your point is not that ranking is invalid, but that you don't understand why people would want to think about it. That's fine, but many of us just enjoy it.
__________________
www.myspace.com/infinityad
Magic Wheel Memory is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 05:03 PM   #16
demonrail666
invito al cielo
 
demonrail666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 18,510
demonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by summer
...but there never will be a situation in which I will have only one album from one particular band,

extra time? golden goal? penalty shoot-out?
demonrail666 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 05.09.2009, 06:01 PM   #17
atsonicpark
invito al cielo
 
atsonicpark's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 28,843
atsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's asses
 
__________________




 
atsonicpark is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 07.17.2009, 05:08 AM   #18
frades
children of satan
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: tours (france)
Posts: 269
frades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's assesfrades kicks all y'all's asses
that's how I'd rank SY's albums 1 to 16, now that we can list "the eternal" in


1 - A Thousand Leaves
2 - Dirty
3 - Washing Machine
4 - Whitey album
5 - Daydream nation
6 - Confusion is sex
7 - Sonic Nurse ( with bonus kim chords )
8 - Expérimental, jet set, trash and no star
9 - Evol
10 - the Eternal
11 - Bad Moon rising
12 - Goo
13 - NYC ghost and flowers
14 - Rather Ripped (with bonus eyeliner - helen lundenberg )
15 - Sister
16 - Murray street ( with bonus kali yug express )
frades is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 07.17.2009, 05:12 AM   #19
atsonicpark
invito al cielo
 
atsonicpark's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 28,843
atsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's asses
They say you can learn more about filmmaking from studying bad movies than you can from good ones. In theory, no one actually intends to make a bad movie, so in order for a movie to become one, something must have gone wrong. By studying these movies, you find out what it was that made them so bad, and can learn from the mistakes that were made.
__________________




 
atsonicpark is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 07.17.2009, 05:43 AM   #20
demonrail666
invito al cielo
 
demonrail666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 18,510
demonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by atsonicpark
They say you can learn more about filmmaking from studying bad movies than you can from good ones. In theory, no one actually intends to make a bad movie, so in order for a movie to become one, something must have gone wrong. By studying these movies, you find out what it was that made them so bad, and can learn from the mistakes that were made.

There's a guy in the US who teaches film along those very lines. It's causing a bit of a stir, not because people think its a bad idea but because nobody can agree on what he chooses as 'bad' movies.
demonrail666 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|


Thread Tools

All content ©2006 Sonic Youth