Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Copycat bands (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=12207)

Danny Himself 04.15.2007 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZEROpumpkins
SM said in the Slanted and Enchanted Deluxe book that that album spawned a thousand weezers, one of which was actually Weezer.


Yeah, I was going to mention Weezer. They have CRCR tapped, the 'ooh ooh's, the geekiness..

fluxequalsrad 04.15.2007 12:43 PM

some others:
Hum ripps off the smashing pumpkins (just listen to the song 'stars' and try not to think of 'drown')

Mogwai wishes they were Slint, Explosions in the Sky wishes they were Mogwai. (I don't really like Mogwai or EITS)

Grandaddy ripps off Pavement (but in such a lovely way, totally excused)

Band of Horses singer sounds like The Shins singer (two different bands though I guess)

MellySingsDoom 04.15.2007 12:46 PM

Bastro borrowed very heavily from Big Black.
Hurricane #1 were essentially a carbon copy of Oasis, complete with idiot mouthy singer and Noel Gallagher-obsessed songwriter.

Sonic Youth 37 04.15.2007 12:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fluxequalsrad
some others:
Hum ripps off the smashing pumpkins (just listen to the song 'stars' and try not to think of 'drown')

Mogwai wishes they were Slint, Explosions in the Sky wishes they were Mogwai. (I don't really like Mogwai or EITS)

Grandaddy ripps off Pavement (but in such a lovely way, totally excused)

Band of Horses singer sounds like The Shins singer (two different bands though I guess)


Hum wasn't a rip off band. "Stars" does sound like The Smashing Pumpkins, but the rest of their stuff was totally creative. Plus, they have the whole space-rock vibe that the Pumpkins never had.

fluxequalsrad 04.15.2007 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37
Hum wasn't a rip off band. "Stars" does sound like The Smashing Pumpkins, but the rest of their stuff was totally creative. Plus, they have the whole space-rock vibe that the Pumpkins never had.


Hum is one of my favorite bands.- no worries

Does anyone know a good Fall album to start off with?

MellySingsDoom 04.15.2007 01:50 PM

fluxequalsrad - on the Fall tip, start off with something like "Grotesque", and then pick up "Hex Enduction Hour" if you like that. The Fall back catalogue is huge, but to me at least, you can't go wrong with the early stuff.

fluxequalsrad 04.15.2007 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MellySingsDoom
fluxequalsrad - on the Fall tip, start off with something like "Grotesque", and then pick up "Hex Enduction Hour" if you like that. The Fall back catalogue is huge, but to me at least, you can't go wrong with the early stuff.


thanks. now to find it all...

atsonicpark 04.15.2007 03:18 PM

Fudge Tunnel ruled. Reminded me more of Unsane than Godflesh but it'sa ll the same.

timtimtim 04.15.2007 11:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
relative ash were a deftones ripoff band; one of their songs is the note sequence to nosebleed backwards.


I used to be a metal junky and never thought that relative ash sounded at all like the deftones. Relative ash is much more metal and harder than anyhin i've heard from the deftones. The singing is very different as well.

timtimtim 04.15.2007 11:48 PM

it seems like most people are naming bands that are similar and the bands that cashe din on pervious bands successes.

Bertrand 04.16.2007 02:34 AM

I can't recall properly, but a member of Sonic Youth could have been annoyed by a fellow band when they were on Blast First, the name being A.C. Temple. The only song I heard is Sheikh on Nothing Short of Total War, and as it sounds like mid-eighties Sonic Youth without the menace, I tend to be sceptical.

The gleeful Herman Düne is 100% Jonathan Richman.

SonicSam 04.16.2007 03:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fluxequalsrad
some others:
Hum ripps off the smashing pumpkins (just listen to the song 'stars' and try not to think of 'drown')

Mogwai wishes they were Slint, Explosions in the Sky wishes they were Mogwai. (I don't really like Mogwai or EITS)

Grandaddy ripps off Pavement (but in such a lovely way, totally excused)

Band of Horses singer sounds like The Shins singer (two different bands though I guess)


yeah, I dont reckon hum sound like SP. Plus, pre stars hum is way greater than post stars hum. Also mogwai pretty much sound nothing like slint - totally different! Maybe their early stuff sounds a bit like them, but definately not their newer stuff.

jon boy 04.16.2007 03:44 AM

if you want bands that sound like other bands then move to leeds. apart from the odd (and good) exeption the place is bereft of original thought and an emulation of certain 'key' bands as they are seen. legends in their own postcode.

auto-aim 04.16.2007 02:06 PM

Oasis anyone?

timtimtim 04.16.2007 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bertrand
The gleeful Herman Düne is 100% Jonathan Richman.

What?
I don't think they are that similar. Also, Herman Dune and David Ivar solo are quite different and better, in my opinion.

sarramkrop 04.19.2007 03:24 PM

The original Courtney:

Courtney Love-The Second Most
Beautiful Girl In the World
mp3

K Records EP, 1990

Lois Maffeo is a national treasure, and the three 7"s she made with Patrick Maley (drummer and YoYo Studio guy) under the name Courtney Love (two on K, One on Feel Good All Over) are all to be prized. (Someone really ought to round them up on a CD.) Her peculiar haunting melodic sense and beautiful wordplay have touched us many times, but this song is probably our favorite.

No relation to that other Courtney Love, that one whose band sounded like Sonic Youth until grunge took over and she realized she'd hopped on the wrong carousel. The one who represented the very apex of alternarock self-absorption with "Doll Parts." The one who sold millions of records and landed a spot on Spin's "Top 100 Alternative Albums" list. The one who was so traumatized by the death of her husband that she no longer appears to be able to write songs. The one who at present amounts to nothing except a punchline of a joke that is now more pathetic than funny.






 

Rob Instigator 04.19.2007 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656
im not saying that pavement toally ripped off th fall, im not belittling the love i have for pavement or the fall.. all im saying is listen to new face in hell and then conduit for sale.... thats all...


that's two songs. pavement have a large discography, of which only the westing and slanted sound anything like the fall


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:31 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth